Functions satisfying $f(a+b) =frac{f(a)+f(b)}{f(a)*f(b)}$
up vote
5
down vote
favorite
i was looking for a function that satisfies $f(a+b) =frac{f(a)+f(b)}{f(a)*f(b)}$ for all $a,b in Bbb{N}$. I have never seen such a problem before and i would like some kind of help to get me started.
functions functional-equations
|
show 3 more comments
up vote
5
down vote
favorite
i was looking for a function that satisfies $f(a+b) =frac{f(a)+f(b)}{f(a)*f(b)}$ for all $a,b in Bbb{N}$. I have never seen such a problem before and i would like some kind of help to get me started.
functions functional-equations
2
Try to find $f(0)$. You will get three values of it, and check what happens with these three values.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:51
2
So $f(0)^3=2f(0)$
– asddf
Nov 25 at 18:54
1
Exactly. Now you see, $f(0)$ can be $0$, $√2$ and $-√2$. Now take one of them and see what happens.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 19:01
2
Having found $f(0)$ i can substitute b=0 and then i have a closed expression for $f(a)$ ? is that the idea ?
– asddf
Nov 25 at 19:07
1
I am not sure why there are supposed to be three values. $f(a)=0$ is clearly impossible for any $a$ since the functional equation is then not defined.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:41
|
show 3 more comments
up vote
5
down vote
favorite
up vote
5
down vote
favorite
i was looking for a function that satisfies $f(a+b) =frac{f(a)+f(b)}{f(a)*f(b)}$ for all $a,b in Bbb{N}$. I have never seen such a problem before and i would like some kind of help to get me started.
functions functional-equations
i was looking for a function that satisfies $f(a+b) =frac{f(a)+f(b)}{f(a)*f(b)}$ for all $a,b in Bbb{N}$. I have never seen such a problem before and i would like some kind of help to get me started.
functions functional-equations
functions functional-equations
edited Nov 26 at 1:32
Enrico Borba
424139
424139
asked Nov 25 at 18:47
asddf
815619
815619
2
Try to find $f(0)$. You will get three values of it, and check what happens with these three values.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:51
2
So $f(0)^3=2f(0)$
– asddf
Nov 25 at 18:54
1
Exactly. Now you see, $f(0)$ can be $0$, $√2$ and $-√2$. Now take one of them and see what happens.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 19:01
2
Having found $f(0)$ i can substitute b=0 and then i have a closed expression for $f(a)$ ? is that the idea ?
– asddf
Nov 25 at 19:07
1
I am not sure why there are supposed to be three values. $f(a)=0$ is clearly impossible for any $a$ since the functional equation is then not defined.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:41
|
show 3 more comments
2
Try to find $f(0)$. You will get three values of it, and check what happens with these three values.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:51
2
So $f(0)^3=2f(0)$
– asddf
Nov 25 at 18:54
1
Exactly. Now you see, $f(0)$ can be $0$, $√2$ and $-√2$. Now take one of them and see what happens.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 19:01
2
Having found $f(0)$ i can substitute b=0 and then i have a closed expression for $f(a)$ ? is that the idea ?
– asddf
Nov 25 at 19:07
1
I am not sure why there are supposed to be three values. $f(a)=0$ is clearly impossible for any $a$ since the functional equation is then not defined.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:41
2
2
Try to find $f(0)$. You will get three values of it, and check what happens with these three values.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:51
Try to find $f(0)$. You will get three values of it, and check what happens with these three values.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:51
2
2
So $f(0)^3=2f(0)$
– asddf
Nov 25 at 18:54
So $f(0)^3=2f(0)$
– asddf
Nov 25 at 18:54
1
1
Exactly. Now you see, $f(0)$ can be $0$, $√2$ and $-√2$. Now take one of them and see what happens.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 19:01
Exactly. Now you see, $f(0)$ can be $0$, $√2$ and $-√2$. Now take one of them and see what happens.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 19:01
2
2
Having found $f(0)$ i can substitute b=0 and then i have a closed expression for $f(a)$ ? is that the idea ?
– asddf
Nov 25 at 19:07
Having found $f(0)$ i can substitute b=0 and then i have a closed expression for $f(a)$ ? is that the idea ?
– asddf
Nov 25 at 19:07
1
1
I am not sure why there are supposed to be three values. $f(a)=0$ is clearly impossible for any $a$ since the functional equation is then not defined.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:41
I am not sure why there are supposed to be three values. $f(a)=0$ is clearly impossible for any $a$ since the functional equation is then not defined.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:41
|
show 3 more comments
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
Asume that $f$ is defined on ${mathbb N}_{geq1}$, and let $f(1):=c$ for a $cindot{mathbb C}$ to be determined. From
$$f(n+1)={1over c}+{1over f(n)}qquad(ngeq1)$$
we compute
$$bigl(f(n)bigr)_{1leq nleq 5}=left(c,{2over c},{2+c^2over 2c},{2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)},{2+5c^2+c^4over c(2+3c^2)}right) .tag{1}$$
Now we should have
$$f(4)=f(2+2)={2 f(2)over bigl(f(2)bigr)^2}={2over f(2)}=c .$$
Comparing this with the value of $f(4)$ in $(1)$ we obtain the equation
$$c={2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)}$$
with the solutions $pm i$ and $pmsqrt{2}$. Starting anew with
$$f(5)=f(2+3)=ldots ,$$
and comparing with the $f(5)$ from the table $(1)$ leads again to $c=pmsqrt{2}$ and to four complex $c$-values $nepm i$. It follows that necessarily $cin{pmsqrt{2}}$. It is then easily checked that the function $f(n):=c$ for all $ngeq1$ satisfies the given functional equation.
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
It is not always clear whether $mathbb N$ includes $0$ or not. If we ignore zero, then one way of working is to set $f(1)=x$ whence:
$$f(2)=f(1+1)=frac 2x$$
$$f(3)=f(2+1)=frac {x^2+2}{2x}$$
$$f(4)=f(3+1)=frac {3x^2+2}{x^3+2x}$$but also $$f(4)=f(2+2)=x$$
In fact we have $f(2a)=f(a+a)=frac 2{f(a)}$ so that $f(a)f(2a)=2=f(2a)f(4a)$ so that always $f(4a)=f(a)$
Equating the expressions for $f(4)$ gives an equation which can be solved for possible values of $x$
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
Assuming $0in mathbb{N}$ we get $f(0)=pm sqrt 2$ as noted in comments.
- Let $f(0)=sqrt 2$
Then $f(1)=frac{f(1)+f(0)}{f(1)cdot f(0)}=frac{f(1)+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2 cdot f(1)}$ leads to the quadratic equation $sqrt 2 cdot [f(1)]^2-f(1)-sqrt 2 =0$ wich has solutions $f(1)=sqrt 2;$ and $;f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$
$f(1)=sqrt 2;$ leads necessarily to $$;f(a)=sqrt 2quadtext{for}quad ain mathbb{N},$$ because the sequence defined as $a_1=sqrt 2,; a_{n+1}=frac{a_n+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2cdot a_n},; nin mathbb{N};$ is constant.
Consider $f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$ We get $$f(2)=frac{2}{f(1)}=-2sqrt2,quad f(3)=frac{f(2)+f(1)}{f(2)f(1)}=-frac{5sqrt 2}{4},$$ but then we would obtain two different values of $f(4):$ $$f(4)=frac{2}{f(2)}=-frac{sqrt2}{2}quad text{or}quad f(4)=frac{f(3)+f(1)}{f(3)f(1)}=-frac{7sqrt2}{5}$$
Therefore $f(1)=sqrt2$ and the function is constant.
Let $f(0)=-sqrt 2$
Similarly to the above, $f(1)$ can take two values.
$f(1)=-sqrt2$ determines a constant solution $f(n)=-sqrt2,$- the other is $f(1)=frac{sqrt2}{2}$ and leads to a disambiguation.
Conclusion
The only solutions defined in $0$ are the constant functions $f(n)=sqrt2;$ and $g(n)=-sqrt 2, n=0,1,;dots$
add a comment |
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
3 Answers
3
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
Asume that $f$ is defined on ${mathbb N}_{geq1}$, and let $f(1):=c$ for a $cindot{mathbb C}$ to be determined. From
$$f(n+1)={1over c}+{1over f(n)}qquad(ngeq1)$$
we compute
$$bigl(f(n)bigr)_{1leq nleq 5}=left(c,{2over c},{2+c^2over 2c},{2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)},{2+5c^2+c^4over c(2+3c^2)}right) .tag{1}$$
Now we should have
$$f(4)=f(2+2)={2 f(2)over bigl(f(2)bigr)^2}={2over f(2)}=c .$$
Comparing this with the value of $f(4)$ in $(1)$ we obtain the equation
$$c={2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)}$$
with the solutions $pm i$ and $pmsqrt{2}$. Starting anew with
$$f(5)=f(2+3)=ldots ,$$
and comparing with the $f(5)$ from the table $(1)$ leads again to $c=pmsqrt{2}$ and to four complex $c$-values $nepm i$. It follows that necessarily $cin{pmsqrt{2}}$. It is then easily checked that the function $f(n):=c$ for all $ngeq1$ satisfies the given functional equation.
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
Asume that $f$ is defined on ${mathbb N}_{geq1}$, and let $f(1):=c$ for a $cindot{mathbb C}$ to be determined. From
$$f(n+1)={1over c}+{1over f(n)}qquad(ngeq1)$$
we compute
$$bigl(f(n)bigr)_{1leq nleq 5}=left(c,{2over c},{2+c^2over 2c},{2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)},{2+5c^2+c^4over c(2+3c^2)}right) .tag{1}$$
Now we should have
$$f(4)=f(2+2)={2 f(2)over bigl(f(2)bigr)^2}={2over f(2)}=c .$$
Comparing this with the value of $f(4)$ in $(1)$ we obtain the equation
$$c={2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)}$$
with the solutions $pm i$ and $pmsqrt{2}$. Starting anew with
$$f(5)=f(2+3)=ldots ,$$
and comparing with the $f(5)$ from the table $(1)$ leads again to $c=pmsqrt{2}$ and to four complex $c$-values $nepm i$. It follows that necessarily $cin{pmsqrt{2}}$. It is then easily checked that the function $f(n):=c$ for all $ngeq1$ satisfies the given functional equation.
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
up vote
2
down vote
accepted
Asume that $f$ is defined on ${mathbb N}_{geq1}$, and let $f(1):=c$ for a $cindot{mathbb C}$ to be determined. From
$$f(n+1)={1over c}+{1over f(n)}qquad(ngeq1)$$
we compute
$$bigl(f(n)bigr)_{1leq nleq 5}=left(c,{2over c},{2+c^2over 2c},{2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)},{2+5c^2+c^4over c(2+3c^2)}right) .tag{1}$$
Now we should have
$$f(4)=f(2+2)={2 f(2)over bigl(f(2)bigr)^2}={2over f(2)}=c .$$
Comparing this with the value of $f(4)$ in $(1)$ we obtain the equation
$$c={2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)}$$
with the solutions $pm i$ and $pmsqrt{2}$. Starting anew with
$$f(5)=f(2+3)=ldots ,$$
and comparing with the $f(5)$ from the table $(1)$ leads again to $c=pmsqrt{2}$ and to four complex $c$-values $nepm i$. It follows that necessarily $cin{pmsqrt{2}}$. It is then easily checked that the function $f(n):=c$ for all $ngeq1$ satisfies the given functional equation.
Asume that $f$ is defined on ${mathbb N}_{geq1}$, and let $f(1):=c$ for a $cindot{mathbb C}$ to be determined. From
$$f(n+1)={1over c}+{1over f(n)}qquad(ngeq1)$$
we compute
$$bigl(f(n)bigr)_{1leq nleq 5}=left(c,{2over c},{2+c^2over 2c},{2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)},{2+5c^2+c^4over c(2+3c^2)}right) .tag{1}$$
Now we should have
$$f(4)=f(2+2)={2 f(2)over bigl(f(2)bigr)^2}={2over f(2)}=c .$$
Comparing this with the value of $f(4)$ in $(1)$ we obtain the equation
$$c={2+3c^2over c(2+c^2)}$$
with the solutions $pm i$ and $pmsqrt{2}$. Starting anew with
$$f(5)=f(2+3)=ldots ,$$
and comparing with the $f(5)$ from the table $(1)$ leads again to $c=pmsqrt{2}$ and to four complex $c$-values $nepm i$. It follows that necessarily $cin{pmsqrt{2}}$. It is then easily checked that the function $f(n):=c$ for all $ngeq1$ satisfies the given functional equation.
answered Nov 25 at 20:24
Christian Blatter
171k7111325
171k7111325
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
It is not always clear whether $mathbb N$ includes $0$ or not. If we ignore zero, then one way of working is to set $f(1)=x$ whence:
$$f(2)=f(1+1)=frac 2x$$
$$f(3)=f(2+1)=frac {x^2+2}{2x}$$
$$f(4)=f(3+1)=frac {3x^2+2}{x^3+2x}$$but also $$f(4)=f(2+2)=x$$
In fact we have $f(2a)=f(a+a)=frac 2{f(a)}$ so that $f(a)f(2a)=2=f(2a)f(4a)$ so that always $f(4a)=f(a)$
Equating the expressions for $f(4)$ gives an equation which can be solved for possible values of $x$
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
It is not always clear whether $mathbb N$ includes $0$ or not. If we ignore zero, then one way of working is to set $f(1)=x$ whence:
$$f(2)=f(1+1)=frac 2x$$
$$f(3)=f(2+1)=frac {x^2+2}{2x}$$
$$f(4)=f(3+1)=frac {3x^2+2}{x^3+2x}$$but also $$f(4)=f(2+2)=x$$
In fact we have $f(2a)=f(a+a)=frac 2{f(a)}$ so that $f(a)f(2a)=2=f(2a)f(4a)$ so that always $f(4a)=f(a)$
Equating the expressions for $f(4)$ gives an equation which can be solved for possible values of $x$
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
It is not always clear whether $mathbb N$ includes $0$ or not. If we ignore zero, then one way of working is to set $f(1)=x$ whence:
$$f(2)=f(1+1)=frac 2x$$
$$f(3)=f(2+1)=frac {x^2+2}{2x}$$
$$f(4)=f(3+1)=frac {3x^2+2}{x^3+2x}$$but also $$f(4)=f(2+2)=x$$
In fact we have $f(2a)=f(a+a)=frac 2{f(a)}$ so that $f(a)f(2a)=2=f(2a)f(4a)$ so that always $f(4a)=f(a)$
Equating the expressions for $f(4)$ gives an equation which can be solved for possible values of $x$
It is not always clear whether $mathbb N$ includes $0$ or not. If we ignore zero, then one way of working is to set $f(1)=x$ whence:
$$f(2)=f(1+1)=frac 2x$$
$$f(3)=f(2+1)=frac {x^2+2}{2x}$$
$$f(4)=f(3+1)=frac {3x^2+2}{x^3+2x}$$but also $$f(4)=f(2+2)=x$$
In fact we have $f(2a)=f(a+a)=frac 2{f(a)}$ so that $f(a)f(2a)=2=f(2a)f(4a)$ so that always $f(4a)=f(a)$
Equating the expressions for $f(4)$ gives an equation which can be solved for possible values of $x$
answered Nov 25 at 20:11
Mark Bennet
80k980178
80k980178
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
Assuming $0in mathbb{N}$ we get $f(0)=pm sqrt 2$ as noted in comments.
- Let $f(0)=sqrt 2$
Then $f(1)=frac{f(1)+f(0)}{f(1)cdot f(0)}=frac{f(1)+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2 cdot f(1)}$ leads to the quadratic equation $sqrt 2 cdot [f(1)]^2-f(1)-sqrt 2 =0$ wich has solutions $f(1)=sqrt 2;$ and $;f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$
$f(1)=sqrt 2;$ leads necessarily to $$;f(a)=sqrt 2quadtext{for}quad ain mathbb{N},$$ because the sequence defined as $a_1=sqrt 2,; a_{n+1}=frac{a_n+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2cdot a_n},; nin mathbb{N};$ is constant.
Consider $f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$ We get $$f(2)=frac{2}{f(1)}=-2sqrt2,quad f(3)=frac{f(2)+f(1)}{f(2)f(1)}=-frac{5sqrt 2}{4},$$ but then we would obtain two different values of $f(4):$ $$f(4)=frac{2}{f(2)}=-frac{sqrt2}{2}quad text{or}quad f(4)=frac{f(3)+f(1)}{f(3)f(1)}=-frac{7sqrt2}{5}$$
Therefore $f(1)=sqrt2$ and the function is constant.
Let $f(0)=-sqrt 2$
Similarly to the above, $f(1)$ can take two values.
$f(1)=-sqrt2$ determines a constant solution $f(n)=-sqrt2,$- the other is $f(1)=frac{sqrt2}{2}$ and leads to a disambiguation.
Conclusion
The only solutions defined in $0$ are the constant functions $f(n)=sqrt2;$ and $g(n)=-sqrt 2, n=0,1,;dots$
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
Assuming $0in mathbb{N}$ we get $f(0)=pm sqrt 2$ as noted in comments.
- Let $f(0)=sqrt 2$
Then $f(1)=frac{f(1)+f(0)}{f(1)cdot f(0)}=frac{f(1)+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2 cdot f(1)}$ leads to the quadratic equation $sqrt 2 cdot [f(1)]^2-f(1)-sqrt 2 =0$ wich has solutions $f(1)=sqrt 2;$ and $;f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$
$f(1)=sqrt 2;$ leads necessarily to $$;f(a)=sqrt 2quadtext{for}quad ain mathbb{N},$$ because the sequence defined as $a_1=sqrt 2,; a_{n+1}=frac{a_n+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2cdot a_n},; nin mathbb{N};$ is constant.
Consider $f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$ We get $$f(2)=frac{2}{f(1)}=-2sqrt2,quad f(3)=frac{f(2)+f(1)}{f(2)f(1)}=-frac{5sqrt 2}{4},$$ but then we would obtain two different values of $f(4):$ $$f(4)=frac{2}{f(2)}=-frac{sqrt2}{2}quad text{or}quad f(4)=frac{f(3)+f(1)}{f(3)f(1)}=-frac{7sqrt2}{5}$$
Therefore $f(1)=sqrt2$ and the function is constant.
Let $f(0)=-sqrt 2$
Similarly to the above, $f(1)$ can take two values.
$f(1)=-sqrt2$ determines a constant solution $f(n)=-sqrt2,$- the other is $f(1)=frac{sqrt2}{2}$ and leads to a disambiguation.
Conclusion
The only solutions defined in $0$ are the constant functions $f(n)=sqrt2;$ and $g(n)=-sqrt 2, n=0,1,;dots$
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
Assuming $0in mathbb{N}$ we get $f(0)=pm sqrt 2$ as noted in comments.
- Let $f(0)=sqrt 2$
Then $f(1)=frac{f(1)+f(0)}{f(1)cdot f(0)}=frac{f(1)+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2 cdot f(1)}$ leads to the quadratic equation $sqrt 2 cdot [f(1)]^2-f(1)-sqrt 2 =0$ wich has solutions $f(1)=sqrt 2;$ and $;f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$
$f(1)=sqrt 2;$ leads necessarily to $$;f(a)=sqrt 2quadtext{for}quad ain mathbb{N},$$ because the sequence defined as $a_1=sqrt 2,; a_{n+1}=frac{a_n+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2cdot a_n},; nin mathbb{N};$ is constant.
Consider $f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$ We get $$f(2)=frac{2}{f(1)}=-2sqrt2,quad f(3)=frac{f(2)+f(1)}{f(2)f(1)}=-frac{5sqrt 2}{4},$$ but then we would obtain two different values of $f(4):$ $$f(4)=frac{2}{f(2)}=-frac{sqrt2}{2}quad text{or}quad f(4)=frac{f(3)+f(1)}{f(3)f(1)}=-frac{7sqrt2}{5}$$
Therefore $f(1)=sqrt2$ and the function is constant.
Let $f(0)=-sqrt 2$
Similarly to the above, $f(1)$ can take two values.
$f(1)=-sqrt2$ determines a constant solution $f(n)=-sqrt2,$- the other is $f(1)=frac{sqrt2}{2}$ and leads to a disambiguation.
Conclusion
The only solutions defined in $0$ are the constant functions $f(n)=sqrt2;$ and $g(n)=-sqrt 2, n=0,1,;dots$
Assuming $0in mathbb{N}$ we get $f(0)=pm sqrt 2$ as noted in comments.
- Let $f(0)=sqrt 2$
Then $f(1)=frac{f(1)+f(0)}{f(1)cdot f(0)}=frac{f(1)+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2 cdot f(1)}$ leads to the quadratic equation $sqrt 2 cdot [f(1)]^2-f(1)-sqrt 2 =0$ wich has solutions $f(1)=sqrt 2;$ and $;f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$
$f(1)=sqrt 2;$ leads necessarily to $$;f(a)=sqrt 2quadtext{for}quad ain mathbb{N},$$ because the sequence defined as $a_1=sqrt 2,; a_{n+1}=frac{a_n+sqrt 2}{sqrt 2cdot a_n},; nin mathbb{N};$ is constant.
Consider $f(1)=-frac{sqrt 2}{2}.$ We get $$f(2)=frac{2}{f(1)}=-2sqrt2,quad f(3)=frac{f(2)+f(1)}{f(2)f(1)}=-frac{5sqrt 2}{4},$$ but then we would obtain two different values of $f(4):$ $$f(4)=frac{2}{f(2)}=-frac{sqrt2}{2}quad text{or}quad f(4)=frac{f(3)+f(1)}{f(3)f(1)}=-frac{7sqrt2}{5}$$
Therefore $f(1)=sqrt2$ and the function is constant.
Let $f(0)=-sqrt 2$
Similarly to the above, $f(1)$ can take two values.
$f(1)=-sqrt2$ determines a constant solution $f(n)=-sqrt2,$- the other is $f(1)=frac{sqrt2}{2}$ and leads to a disambiguation.
Conclusion
The only solutions defined in $0$ are the constant functions $f(n)=sqrt2;$ and $g(n)=-sqrt 2, n=0,1,;dots$
answered Nov 25 at 23:57
user376343
2,6432819
2,6432819
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3013214%2ffunctions-satisfying-fab-fracfafbfafb%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
Try to find $f(0)$. You will get three values of it, and check what happens with these three values.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:51
2
So $f(0)^3=2f(0)$
– asddf
Nov 25 at 18:54
1
Exactly. Now you see, $f(0)$ can be $0$, $√2$ and $-√2$. Now take one of them and see what happens.
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 19:01
2
Having found $f(0)$ i can substitute b=0 and then i have a closed expression for $f(a)$ ? is that the idea ?
– asddf
Nov 25 at 19:07
1
I am not sure why there are supposed to be three values. $f(a)=0$ is clearly impossible for any $a$ since the functional equation is then not defined.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:41