Show $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13} =10k$ without direct calculation
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
Prove that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
Obviously you could just put that in to a calculator and see the results, but I was wondering about some of the other approaches to this? I have not studied modulus', so if you could explain it without them, it would be better for me. Thanks!
elementary-number-theory arithmetic divisibility
|
show 1 more comment
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
Prove that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
Obviously you could just put that in to a calculator and see the results, but I was wondering about some of the other approaches to this? I have not studied modulus', so if you could explain it without them, it would be better for me. Thanks!
elementary-number-theory arithmetic divisibility
2
Do calculators now have enough precision to compute $13^{13}$ exactly?
– MJD
Nov 25 at 18:50
1
What about taking mod $10$ ??
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:52
1
Working modulo $10$ is simply the same as only looking at the final digit. There are all sorts of ways of approaching this. The most efficient ones will use the tricks of modular arithmetic, which were designed for just such problems and encode the patterns which you will notice if you do more of the calculations by hand. I am sure you will get some elementary answers, but it is worth noting some of the other things people say as well, and either look them up, or look out for them as you learn, because you will find they come in handy to know.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:18
If $n$ has a last digit of $a$ and $m$ has a last digit of $b$ then $n =10k +a$ and $m=10j + b$. Note: $n^z=(10k + a)^z$ and all we are interested in is the last digit then it has the same last digit as $a^z$. And $n + m = 10k + 10j + a + b$ so we only have to consider those last digits. So this become a math based on "last digits" and that's much easier.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:28
FYI: Modulus arithmetic simply means doing arithmetic on remainders. The important thing is that to find the remainder of an expression with large values, it is good enough to do the expression on just the remainders. So the remaider of $32^9*43+52$ when divided by $7$ it's enough to take the remainder of $32:(4)$, the remainder of $43:(1)$ and the remainder of $52:(3)$ an find out the remainder of $4^9*1+3$. And to figure and $4^9$ we figure $4^2=16$ has remainder $2$. So $4^3$ has remainder $2*4=8$ which has remainder $1$. And $4^3$ has remainder $1*4=4$ and so on.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 21:50
|
show 1 more comment
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
up vote
2
down vote
favorite
Prove that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
Obviously you could just put that in to a calculator and see the results, but I was wondering about some of the other approaches to this? I have not studied modulus', so if you could explain it without them, it would be better for me. Thanks!
elementary-number-theory arithmetic divisibility
Prove that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
Obviously you could just put that in to a calculator and see the results, but I was wondering about some of the other approaches to this? I have not studied modulus', so if you could explain it without them, it would be better for me. Thanks!
elementary-number-theory arithmetic divisibility
elementary-number-theory arithmetic divisibility
edited Nov 25 at 22:04
greedoid
36.1k114591
36.1k114591
asked Nov 25 at 18:46
乇乂ㄒ尺卂ㄒ卄丨匚匚
142
142
2
Do calculators now have enough precision to compute $13^{13}$ exactly?
– MJD
Nov 25 at 18:50
1
What about taking mod $10$ ??
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:52
1
Working modulo $10$ is simply the same as only looking at the final digit. There are all sorts of ways of approaching this. The most efficient ones will use the tricks of modular arithmetic, which were designed for just such problems and encode the patterns which you will notice if you do more of the calculations by hand. I am sure you will get some elementary answers, but it is worth noting some of the other things people say as well, and either look them up, or look out for them as you learn, because you will find they come in handy to know.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:18
If $n$ has a last digit of $a$ and $m$ has a last digit of $b$ then $n =10k +a$ and $m=10j + b$. Note: $n^z=(10k + a)^z$ and all we are interested in is the last digit then it has the same last digit as $a^z$. And $n + m = 10k + 10j + a + b$ so we only have to consider those last digits. So this become a math based on "last digits" and that's much easier.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:28
FYI: Modulus arithmetic simply means doing arithmetic on remainders. The important thing is that to find the remainder of an expression with large values, it is good enough to do the expression on just the remainders. So the remaider of $32^9*43+52$ when divided by $7$ it's enough to take the remainder of $32:(4)$, the remainder of $43:(1)$ and the remainder of $52:(3)$ an find out the remainder of $4^9*1+3$. And to figure and $4^9$ we figure $4^2=16$ has remainder $2$. So $4^3$ has remainder $2*4=8$ which has remainder $1$. And $4^3$ has remainder $1*4=4$ and so on.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 21:50
|
show 1 more comment
2
Do calculators now have enough precision to compute $13^{13}$ exactly?
– MJD
Nov 25 at 18:50
1
What about taking mod $10$ ??
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:52
1
Working modulo $10$ is simply the same as only looking at the final digit. There are all sorts of ways of approaching this. The most efficient ones will use the tricks of modular arithmetic, which were designed for just such problems and encode the patterns which you will notice if you do more of the calculations by hand. I am sure you will get some elementary answers, but it is worth noting some of the other things people say as well, and either look them up, or look out for them as you learn, because you will find they come in handy to know.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:18
If $n$ has a last digit of $a$ and $m$ has a last digit of $b$ then $n =10k +a$ and $m=10j + b$. Note: $n^z=(10k + a)^z$ and all we are interested in is the last digit then it has the same last digit as $a^z$. And $n + m = 10k + 10j + a + b$ so we only have to consider those last digits. So this become a math based on "last digits" and that's much easier.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:28
FYI: Modulus arithmetic simply means doing arithmetic on remainders. The important thing is that to find the remainder of an expression with large values, it is good enough to do the expression on just the remainders. So the remaider of $32^9*43+52$ when divided by $7$ it's enough to take the remainder of $32:(4)$, the remainder of $43:(1)$ and the remainder of $52:(3)$ an find out the remainder of $4^9*1+3$. And to figure and $4^9$ we figure $4^2=16$ has remainder $2$. So $4^3$ has remainder $2*4=8$ which has remainder $1$. And $4^3$ has remainder $1*4=4$ and so on.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 21:50
2
2
Do calculators now have enough precision to compute $13^{13}$ exactly?
– MJD
Nov 25 at 18:50
Do calculators now have enough precision to compute $13^{13}$ exactly?
– MJD
Nov 25 at 18:50
1
1
What about taking mod $10$ ??
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:52
What about taking mod $10$ ??
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:52
1
1
Working modulo $10$ is simply the same as only looking at the final digit. There are all sorts of ways of approaching this. The most efficient ones will use the tricks of modular arithmetic, which were designed for just such problems and encode the patterns which you will notice if you do more of the calculations by hand. I am sure you will get some elementary answers, but it is worth noting some of the other things people say as well, and either look them up, or look out for them as you learn, because you will find they come in handy to know.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:18
Working modulo $10$ is simply the same as only looking at the final digit. There are all sorts of ways of approaching this. The most efficient ones will use the tricks of modular arithmetic, which were designed for just such problems and encode the patterns which you will notice if you do more of the calculations by hand. I am sure you will get some elementary answers, but it is worth noting some of the other things people say as well, and either look them up, or look out for them as you learn, because you will find they come in handy to know.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:18
If $n$ has a last digit of $a$ and $m$ has a last digit of $b$ then $n =10k +a$ and $m=10j + b$. Note: $n^z=(10k + a)^z$ and all we are interested in is the last digit then it has the same last digit as $a^z$. And $n + m = 10k + 10j + a + b$ so we only have to consider those last digits. So this become a math based on "last digits" and that's much easier.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:28
If $n$ has a last digit of $a$ and $m$ has a last digit of $b$ then $n =10k +a$ and $m=10j + b$. Note: $n^z=(10k + a)^z$ and all we are interested in is the last digit then it has the same last digit as $a^z$. And $n + m = 10k + 10j + a + b$ so we only have to consider those last digits. So this become a math based on "last digits" and that's much easier.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:28
FYI: Modulus arithmetic simply means doing arithmetic on remainders. The important thing is that to find the remainder of an expression with large values, it is good enough to do the expression on just the remainders. So the remaider of $32^9*43+52$ when divided by $7$ it's enough to take the remainder of $32:(4)$, the remainder of $43:(1)$ and the remainder of $52:(3)$ an find out the remainder of $4^9*1+3$. And to figure and $4^9$ we figure $4^2=16$ has remainder $2$. So $4^3$ has remainder $2*4=8$ which has remainder $1$. And $4^3$ has remainder $1*4=4$ and so on.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 21:50
FYI: Modulus arithmetic simply means doing arithmetic on remainders. The important thing is that to find the remainder of an expression with large values, it is good enough to do the expression on just the remainders. So the remaider of $32^9*43+52$ when divided by $7$ it's enough to take the remainder of $32:(4)$, the remainder of $43:(1)$ and the remainder of $52:(3)$ an find out the remainder of $4^9*1+3$. And to figure and $4^9$ we figure $4^2=16$ has remainder $2$. So $4^3$ has remainder $2*4=8$ which has remainder $1$. And $4^3$ has remainder $1*4=4$ and so on.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 21:50
|
show 1 more comment
13 Answers
13
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
$13^4$ ends with $1$ so does $13^{12}$ and thus $13^{13}$ ends with $3$
$12^4$ ends with $6$ so $12^{12}$ also ends with $6$
$11^{11}$ ends with $1$ so your statement is valid.
1
How do you know $13^4$ ends with $1$? I'd add words to the effect you can find the last digit by only considering the last digit (because everything else is a multiple of 10).
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:23
$13^2$ ends with 9 so $13^4$ ends with...
– greedoid
Nov 25 at 19:24
1
Right, but I think we should spell it out gently.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 22:32
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
Using the fact that $a^4equiv1$ mod $5$ if $5notmid a$, we find
$$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv
begin{cases}1+0+1equiv0mod 2\
1+1+3equiv0mod 5
end{cases}$$
Added later: Here is an alternative way to show that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ without resorting to modular arguments. All that's needed is the algebraic identity $x^n-y^n=(x-y)(x^{n-1}+x^{n-2}y+cdots+xy^{n-2}+y^{n-1})$ with various interpretations of $x$, $y$, and $n$ (e.g., $x=12^4$, $y=6^4$ and $n=3$).
Note that $1+6+13=20$ is a multiple of $10$. It follows that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ if and only if $(11^{11}-1)+(12^{12}-6^{12})+(6^{12}-6)+(13^{13}-13)$ is a multiple of $10$. But
$$begin{align}
11^{11}-1&=(11-1)(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
&=10(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
12^{12}-6^{12}&=(12^4-6^4)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(12^2+6^2)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(144+36)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=180(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
6^{12}-6&=6(6^{11}-1)\
&=6(6-1)(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
&=30(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
13^{13}-13&=13(13^{12}-1)\
&=13(13^4-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(13^2+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(169+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13cdot170(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
end{align}$$
Remark: This approach is, of course, more convoluted than the modular approach. (It also relies in part on knowing which terms, such as $12^2+6^2$, will produce a factor of $10$.) If anything, it should demonstrate the value of learning how modular arithmetic works!
2
That's surely beyond the OPs exposure to number theory, don't you think?
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:19
@fleablood, the OP only just now added the disclaimer about not having studied modular arithmetic. Before that it was hard to tell what they did or didn't know.
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 19:26
what does OP refer to, stands for??
– Maged Saeed
Nov 25 at 20:07
1
@MagedSaeed, Original Post(er).
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 20:24
@fleablood The 2nd approach above uses only the Factor Theorem so it is likely accessible to the OP. Slightly more streamlined is to use the Binomial Theorem as I do in my answer, but that's still far from the elegance and simplicity of modular arithmetic .
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 25 at 21:30
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
0
down vote
You might be able to show that the units digit is zero pretty easily.
This is the shortest and most to the point answer!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:01
If MPW provides an example or some steps to show that the units digit is zero, then it will be much appreciated.
– 乇乂ㄒ尺卂ㄒ卄丨匚匚
Nov 25 at 19:06
Well, the trick is to realize that the last digit of $n^k$ is the same as the last digit of the last digit of $n$ to the $k$. So the last digit of $11^{11}$ is the same as the last digit of $1^{11} = 1$ and the last digit of $12^{12}$ is the same as the last digit of $2^{12}$ and the last digit of $13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $3^{13}$. Now you might think finding out the last digit of $3^{13}$ is hard but if we "throw away" every thing but the last digit is easy: $3^2=9; 3^3=9*3=27=7; 3^4=7*3=21=1;3^5=1*3=3;3^6=3*3=9;3^7=9*3=27=7...$ etc. notice that last digit of $3^4$ is $1$.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:16
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Last digit of $11^11$ is obviously 1.
$12^1$ ends at 2. $12^2$ ends at 4. $12^3$ at 8. $12^4$ at 6, and $12^5$ again at 2. So, last digit of $12^{12}$ is 6.
$13^1$ ends at 3. $13^2$ at 9. $13^3$ at 7, $13^4$ ends at 1 and $13^5$ again ends at 3. Hence, $13^{13}$ ends at 3.
Finally, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$$ ends at 0 at your number is divisible by 10.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Simple calculation :
$11 equiv 1 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $11^{11} equiv 1 (mod 10)$
$12 equiv 2 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $12^{12} equiv 6 (mod 10)$
$13 equiv 3 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $13^{13} equiv 3 (mod 10)$
Hence
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv 1+6+3 equiv 0 (mod 10)$
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
The final digit of $11^{11}$ is easy. If we are able to use Fermat-Euler we have that $varphi (10)=4$ so that if $n$ is coprime to $10$ then $n^4equiv 1$ and that applies with $n=3$ so that $13^{13}equiv 3^{12}cdot 3equiv 3 bmod 10$.
$12$ is more interesting - we can't use the coprime property. The exponent is small enough that you can do it by hand, but here is another trick (working modulo $10$).
First $12^{12}equiv 2^{12}$
Then $12^{12}=3^{12}cdot 4^{12}equiv left(2^{12}right)^2$ (we did $3^{12}equiv 1$ already)
Let $2^{12}equiv m$, then $m^2equiv m$ from the two calculations above, and $m$ is even and non-zero, so must be $6$.
I added this because it is interesting, and very occasionally such alternative ways of working save a lot of time.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
You can easily prove it without any modular arithmetic. Just look at the last digits.
$$3^1 = color{blue}{3} quad 3^2 = color{blue}{9} quad 3^3 = 2color{blue}{7} quad 3^4 = 8color{blue}{1} implies 3, 9, 7, 1, 3, 9, 7, 1, ...$$
$$2^1 = color{green}{2} quad 2^2 = color{green}{4} quad 2^3 = color{green}{8} quad 2^4 = 1color{green}{6} implies 2, 4, 8, 6, 2, 4, 8, 6, ...$$
The pattern loops every $4^{th}$ exponent, as you can see. Notice that $13^{13}$ must end with whatever $3^{13}$ ends with, and $2^{12}$ must end with whatever $2^{12}$ ends with.
$$13 = color{purple}{3}(4)+color{blue}{1} quadtext{Three loops done; first exponent}$$
$$12 = color{purple}{2}(4)+color{green}{4} quadtext{Two loops done; fourth exponent}$$
Thus, $13^{13}$ ends with $color{blue}{3}$ and $12^{12}$ ends with $color{green}{6}$. $11^{11}$ obviously ends with $1$, so what does the unit digit become?
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Tedious the first time you do it way but once you do it is obvious:
$$11^{11} = (10 + 1)^{11} = 10^{11} + 11*10^{10} + 55*10^9..... + 55*10^2 + 11*10 + 1 = 10M + 1$$ for $M= 10^{10} + 11*10^{9} + 55*10^8..... + 55*10 + 11$. But ... THE EXACT VALUE OF $M$ WILL NOT MATTER!!!... The only thing that matters is the remander $1$.
Likewise $$12^{12} = (10 + 2)^{12} = 10^{12} + 12*2*10^{11} + 66*2^2*10^{10} + .... . + 66*2^{10}*10^2+ 12*2^{11}*10 + 2^{12} = 10N + 2^{12}$$ for $N = 10^{12} + .... text{oh, what that hell do we care}$.
And $$13^{13} = (10+3)^{13} = 10^{13} + 13*10^{12}*3 + ..... +13*10*3^{12} + 3^{12} = 10K + 3^{13}$$ for $K = text{whatever}$.
So $$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13} = 10N + 10M + 10K + 1 + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$. But since we are only interested in whether it is divisible by $10$ we can ignore the $10N + 10M + 10K$ because it is divisible by $10$.
So for all that tedious work we've come up with the simple and useful idea that "if we want to find out if something is divisible by $10$ we only have to do math on the remainders. We could have done that in our heads!
If $equiv_{10}$ means "has the same remainder when divided by $10$" we could have done that in one line:
$$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}equiv_{10} 1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$
$1^{11} = 1$ of course.
And we can do $2^{12}$ in steps.
$2^2 = 4; 2^4= 4^2 = 16=10+6equiv_{10} 6$.
$2^8 = (10 + 6)^2 = 100 + 2*6*10 + 36= 10M + 6equiv{10} 6$.
So $2^{12} = 2^8*2^4 = (10M + 6)(10 +6) =100M + 6*10 + 10*6M + 6*6equiv_{10}6*6=36equiv_{10} 6$.
At this point we should realize we can just go deirectly to working with remainders.
$3^{2} = 9; 3^4 = 9^2 = 81 equiv_{10} 1$. So $3^{13}3^4*3^4*3^4*3equiv_{10} 1*1*1*3=3$.
So if we had used this concept of remainders from the begining we'd have done it in two or three lines:
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1 + (2^4)^3 +(3^4)^3 times 3 equiv_{10}$
$1 + 16^3 + 81^3*3 equiv $
$1 +6^3 + 1^3*3equiv $
$1 + 36*6 + 3 equiv $
$1 + 6*6 + 3equiv $
$1 + 36 + 3equiv $
$1 + 6 + 3equiv 10 equiv 0$.
So $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ has remainder $0$ when divided by $10$ which is to say $11^11 + 12^{12} +13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
====
A number is devisible by $10$ if and only if the last digit is $0$.
And value of the last digits arithmetically "distribute". That is if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ then the last digit of $n^k$ is the last digit of $a^k$. (Because $n = 10b +a$ so $n^k =(10b + a)^k = abunchofmultiplesof(10) + a^k$) and if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ and the last digit of $m$ is $c$ then the last digit of $m + n$ is the last digit of $b+1$ and the last digit of $mtimes n$ is the last digit of $btimes c$.
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$ if only if its last digit is $0$.
And the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the last digit of $1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}$
$1^{11} = 1$.
$2^{12} = 2^4times 2^4 times 2^4 = 16times 16times 16$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6times 6$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6=36$ so the last digit is $6$.
$3^{13} = 3^4times 3^4 times 3^4 times 3$. $3^4 = 81$ so the last digit of $3^{13}$ is the last digit of $1times1times 1times 3 = 3$>
So the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $1 + 6 + 3 =10$. And that digit is $0$.
So, yes, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Since you don't know modular arithmetic we can instead employ the Binomial Theorem.
Theorem $ 10 $ divides $ (1!+!10a)^{large k}!+ (2!+!10b)^{large 4n}!+(3!+!10c)^{large 1+4n} $ for $,a,b,cinBbb Z, k,nin Bbb N$
Proof $ $ To show it's divisible by $10$ it suffices to show it's divisible by $,2,$ and $,5,$. Notice it has parity odd + even + odd = even, so $,2,$ divides it. Below we show that $,5,$ divides it too.
Note that $ (x,+,color{#c00}5y)^{large m}, =, x^{large m}, +, color{#c00}5(cdots) ,$ by $ rmcolor{#0a0}{BT}$ := Binomial Theorem, for $(cdots)$ an integer.
$!!begin{align} {rm Therefore},
(2+10b)^{large 4n} &= 2^{large 4n},+, 5,i, , text{for an integer } i, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\[.2em]
&= (1!+!15)^{large n}! + 5,i\[,2em]
&= 1 + 5,j, +, 5,i, text{for an integer } j, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\
end{align}$
Similarly $, (1+10a)^{large k} =, 1 + 5,d$
and also $ (3+10c)^{large 1+4n}! = 3 + 5,e$
Therefore their sum equals $: 1 + 1 + 3 + 5(cdots) = $ multiple of $5. $ QED
Alternatively we can replace the Binomial Theorem by the Factor Theorem as follows $$large z^m!-x^m = (z!-!x)(cdots) {rm for} z=x!+!5y, {rm has factor} z-x = color{#c00}5y {rm so is divisible by}, color{#c00}5quad$$ This method is used in Barry's answer. $ $
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 26 at 2:34
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
The first digit of $11^{11}=$ the first digit of $1^{11}=$ $1$.
The first digit of $12^5$ equals the first digit of $2^5=$ the first digit of $32=2$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{10}) =$ (The first digit of $12^5)^2 = 4$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{12}) =
$ (The first digit of $12^{10}) times($The first digit of $12^2) = 6$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{4}) =$ (The first digit of $3^4) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{12}) =$ (The first digit of $(13^4)^3) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{13}) =$ (The first digit of $13^{12} times 3) = 3$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}) =$
(The first digit of $1+6+3) = 0$ }$.
Hence $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Note that $$11equiv1;mathtt{mod}(10) Rightarrow {11^{11}}equiv {1^{11}}equiv1 ;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Analugously $${12^{12}}equiv{2^{12}}equiv{(2^6)^2}equiv{64^2}equiv6;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$${13^{13}}equiv{(13^4)^2}*13equiv{1^2}*3equiv3; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Thus
$${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}equiv1+6+3equiv 0; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$$therefore10mid bigl({11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}bigr)$$
You can alternatively use the binomial theorem:
$$11^{11}=(10+1)^{11}=sum_{k=0}^{11}binom{11}{k}10^k=binom{11}{0}10^0+binom{11}{1}10^1+binom{11}{2}10^2+ldots+binom{11}{11}10^{11}$$
$$=1+11*10+55*100+ldots+10^{11}=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)$$
$$12^{12}=(10+2)^{12}=sum_{k=0}^{12}binom{12}{k}10^k2^{12-k}=binom{12}{0}10^02^{12}+binom{12}{1}10^12^{11}+binom{12}{2}10^22^{10}+ldots+binom{12}{12}10^{12}=2^{12}+12*10*2^{11}+66*100*2^{10}+ldots+10^{12}$$ $$=2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)$$
$$13^{13}=(10+3)^{13}=sum_{k=0}^{13}binom{13}{k}10^k3^{13-k}=binom{13}{0}10^03^{13}+binom{13}{1}10^13^{12}+binom{13}{2}10^23^{11}+ldots+binom{13}{13}10^{13}=3^{13}+13*10*3^{12}+78*100*3^{11}+ldots+10^{13}$$ $$=3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$
Thus $${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}$$ $$=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)+2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)+3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$ $$=1+2^{12}+3^{13}+10Biggl(cdotsBiggr)$$
Now $$1+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+2^{3*4}+3^{3*4}*3=1+8^4+9^4*3=1+64^2+81^2*3$$ $$=1+4096+6561*3=23780Rightarrow 10mid (1+2^{12}+3^{13})$$
And we would be done.
PS:
I still find the modular approach easier and more elegant...
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic.
$11equiv 1mod 10implies 11^{11}equiv 1mod 10$.
$12equiv 2mod 10implies 12^6equiv 2^6 mod10equiv 4mod 10$ $implies 12^{12}equiv 4^2mod 10equiv 6mod 10$.
$13equiv 3 mod 10implies 13^4equiv 3^4 mod 10equiv 1 mod 10implies 13^{13}equiv 3mod 10.$
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv 1+6+3 mod 10equiv 0 mod 10.$
Hence $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by 10.
"Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic." I think that's a big assumption. But $mod 10$ can be explained in one sentence to an extent that the OP can understand it
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:00
But it can get mathematical then. It would be based on logical arguments rather than mathematical deductions.
– Yadati Kiran
Nov 25 at 19:02
I absolutely agree!!!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:17
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
When calculating in (mod 10) we get $11^{11}+12^{12}+12^{13}=1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+6+3=10$. Here I knew $2^{10} =1024$, so $2^{12}=6(mod10)$ and $3$ has order $4$ in $mathbb{Z}/10mathbb{Z}$ so $3^{13}=3^{12}*3=3$.
add a comment |
13 Answers
13
active
oldest
votes
13 Answers
13
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
active
oldest
votes
up vote
2
down vote
$13^4$ ends with $1$ so does $13^{12}$ and thus $13^{13}$ ends with $3$
$12^4$ ends with $6$ so $12^{12}$ also ends with $6$
$11^{11}$ ends with $1$ so your statement is valid.
1
How do you know $13^4$ ends with $1$? I'd add words to the effect you can find the last digit by only considering the last digit (because everything else is a multiple of 10).
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:23
$13^2$ ends with 9 so $13^4$ ends with...
– greedoid
Nov 25 at 19:24
1
Right, but I think we should spell it out gently.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 22:32
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
$13^4$ ends with $1$ so does $13^{12}$ and thus $13^{13}$ ends with $3$
$12^4$ ends with $6$ so $12^{12}$ also ends with $6$
$11^{11}$ ends with $1$ so your statement is valid.
1
How do you know $13^4$ ends with $1$? I'd add words to the effect you can find the last digit by only considering the last digit (because everything else is a multiple of 10).
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:23
$13^2$ ends with 9 so $13^4$ ends with...
– greedoid
Nov 25 at 19:24
1
Right, but I think we should spell it out gently.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 22:32
add a comment |
up vote
2
down vote
up vote
2
down vote
$13^4$ ends with $1$ so does $13^{12}$ and thus $13^{13}$ ends with $3$
$12^4$ ends with $6$ so $12^{12}$ also ends with $6$
$11^{11}$ ends with $1$ so your statement is valid.
$13^4$ ends with $1$ so does $13^{12}$ and thus $13^{13}$ ends with $3$
$12^4$ ends with $6$ so $12^{12}$ also ends with $6$
$11^{11}$ ends with $1$ so your statement is valid.
edited Nov 25 at 21:42
answered Nov 25 at 18:56
greedoid
36.1k114591
36.1k114591
1
How do you know $13^4$ ends with $1$? I'd add words to the effect you can find the last digit by only considering the last digit (because everything else is a multiple of 10).
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:23
$13^2$ ends with 9 so $13^4$ ends with...
– greedoid
Nov 25 at 19:24
1
Right, but I think we should spell it out gently.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 22:32
add a comment |
1
How do you know $13^4$ ends with $1$? I'd add words to the effect you can find the last digit by only considering the last digit (because everything else is a multiple of 10).
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:23
$13^2$ ends with 9 so $13^4$ ends with...
– greedoid
Nov 25 at 19:24
1
Right, but I think we should spell it out gently.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 22:32
1
1
How do you know $13^4$ ends with $1$? I'd add words to the effect you can find the last digit by only considering the last digit (because everything else is a multiple of 10).
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:23
How do you know $13^4$ ends with $1$? I'd add words to the effect you can find the last digit by only considering the last digit (because everything else is a multiple of 10).
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:23
$13^2$ ends with 9 so $13^4$ ends with...
– greedoid
Nov 25 at 19:24
$13^2$ ends with 9 so $13^4$ ends with...
– greedoid
Nov 25 at 19:24
1
1
Right, but I think we should spell it out gently.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 22:32
Right, but I think we should spell it out gently.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 22:32
add a comment |
up vote
1
down vote
Using the fact that $a^4equiv1$ mod $5$ if $5notmid a$, we find
$$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv
begin{cases}1+0+1equiv0mod 2\
1+1+3equiv0mod 5
end{cases}$$
Added later: Here is an alternative way to show that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ without resorting to modular arguments. All that's needed is the algebraic identity $x^n-y^n=(x-y)(x^{n-1}+x^{n-2}y+cdots+xy^{n-2}+y^{n-1})$ with various interpretations of $x$, $y$, and $n$ (e.g., $x=12^4$, $y=6^4$ and $n=3$).
Note that $1+6+13=20$ is a multiple of $10$. It follows that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ if and only if $(11^{11}-1)+(12^{12}-6^{12})+(6^{12}-6)+(13^{13}-13)$ is a multiple of $10$. But
$$begin{align}
11^{11}-1&=(11-1)(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
&=10(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
12^{12}-6^{12}&=(12^4-6^4)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(12^2+6^2)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(144+36)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=180(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
6^{12}-6&=6(6^{11}-1)\
&=6(6-1)(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
&=30(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
13^{13}-13&=13(13^{12}-1)\
&=13(13^4-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(13^2+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(169+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13cdot170(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
end{align}$$
Remark: This approach is, of course, more convoluted than the modular approach. (It also relies in part on knowing which terms, such as $12^2+6^2$, will produce a factor of $10$.) If anything, it should demonstrate the value of learning how modular arithmetic works!
2
That's surely beyond the OPs exposure to number theory, don't you think?
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:19
@fleablood, the OP only just now added the disclaimer about not having studied modular arithmetic. Before that it was hard to tell what they did or didn't know.
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 19:26
what does OP refer to, stands for??
– Maged Saeed
Nov 25 at 20:07
1
@MagedSaeed, Original Post(er).
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 20:24
@fleablood The 2nd approach above uses only the Factor Theorem so it is likely accessible to the OP. Slightly more streamlined is to use the Binomial Theorem as I do in my answer, but that's still far from the elegance and simplicity of modular arithmetic .
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 25 at 21:30
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
1
down vote
Using the fact that $a^4equiv1$ mod $5$ if $5notmid a$, we find
$$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv
begin{cases}1+0+1equiv0mod 2\
1+1+3equiv0mod 5
end{cases}$$
Added later: Here is an alternative way to show that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ without resorting to modular arguments. All that's needed is the algebraic identity $x^n-y^n=(x-y)(x^{n-1}+x^{n-2}y+cdots+xy^{n-2}+y^{n-1})$ with various interpretations of $x$, $y$, and $n$ (e.g., $x=12^4$, $y=6^4$ and $n=3$).
Note that $1+6+13=20$ is a multiple of $10$. It follows that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ if and only if $(11^{11}-1)+(12^{12}-6^{12})+(6^{12}-6)+(13^{13}-13)$ is a multiple of $10$. But
$$begin{align}
11^{11}-1&=(11-1)(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
&=10(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
12^{12}-6^{12}&=(12^4-6^4)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(12^2+6^2)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(144+36)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=180(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
6^{12}-6&=6(6^{11}-1)\
&=6(6-1)(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
&=30(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
13^{13}-13&=13(13^{12}-1)\
&=13(13^4-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(13^2+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(169+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13cdot170(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
end{align}$$
Remark: This approach is, of course, more convoluted than the modular approach. (It also relies in part on knowing which terms, such as $12^2+6^2$, will produce a factor of $10$.) If anything, it should demonstrate the value of learning how modular arithmetic works!
2
That's surely beyond the OPs exposure to number theory, don't you think?
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:19
@fleablood, the OP only just now added the disclaimer about not having studied modular arithmetic. Before that it was hard to tell what they did or didn't know.
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 19:26
what does OP refer to, stands for??
– Maged Saeed
Nov 25 at 20:07
1
@MagedSaeed, Original Post(er).
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 20:24
@fleablood The 2nd approach above uses only the Factor Theorem so it is likely accessible to the OP. Slightly more streamlined is to use the Binomial Theorem as I do in my answer, but that's still far from the elegance and simplicity of modular arithmetic .
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 25 at 21:30
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
1
down vote
up vote
1
down vote
Using the fact that $a^4equiv1$ mod $5$ if $5notmid a$, we find
$$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv
begin{cases}1+0+1equiv0mod 2\
1+1+3equiv0mod 5
end{cases}$$
Added later: Here is an alternative way to show that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ without resorting to modular arguments. All that's needed is the algebraic identity $x^n-y^n=(x-y)(x^{n-1}+x^{n-2}y+cdots+xy^{n-2}+y^{n-1})$ with various interpretations of $x$, $y$, and $n$ (e.g., $x=12^4$, $y=6^4$ and $n=3$).
Note that $1+6+13=20$ is a multiple of $10$. It follows that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ if and only if $(11^{11}-1)+(12^{12}-6^{12})+(6^{12}-6)+(13^{13}-13)$ is a multiple of $10$. But
$$begin{align}
11^{11}-1&=(11-1)(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
&=10(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
12^{12}-6^{12}&=(12^4-6^4)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(12^2+6^2)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(144+36)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=180(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
6^{12}-6&=6(6^{11}-1)\
&=6(6-1)(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
&=30(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
13^{13}-13&=13(13^{12}-1)\
&=13(13^4-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(13^2+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(169+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13cdot170(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
end{align}$$
Remark: This approach is, of course, more convoluted than the modular approach. (It also relies in part on knowing which terms, such as $12^2+6^2$, will produce a factor of $10$.) If anything, it should demonstrate the value of learning how modular arithmetic works!
Using the fact that $a^4equiv1$ mod $5$ if $5notmid a$, we find
$$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv
begin{cases}1+0+1equiv0mod 2\
1+1+3equiv0mod 5
end{cases}$$
Added later: Here is an alternative way to show that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ without resorting to modular arguments. All that's needed is the algebraic identity $x^n-y^n=(x-y)(x^{n-1}+x^{n-2}y+cdots+xy^{n-2}+y^{n-1})$ with various interpretations of $x$, $y$, and $n$ (e.g., $x=12^4$, $y=6^4$ and $n=3$).
Note that $1+6+13=20$ is a multiple of $10$. It follows that $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$ if and only if $(11^{11}-1)+(12^{12}-6^{12})+(6^{12}-6)+(13^{13}-13)$ is a multiple of $10$. But
$$begin{align}
11^{11}-1&=(11-1)(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
&=10(11^{10}+11^9+cdots+11+1)\
12^{12}-6^{12}&=(12^4-6^4)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(12^2+6^2)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=(144+36)(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
&=180(12^2-6^2)(12^8+12^46^4+6^8)\
6^{12}-6&=6(6^{11}-1)\
&=6(6-1)(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
&=30(6^{10}+6^9+cdots+1)\
13^{13}-13&=13(13^{12}-1)\
&=13(13^4-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(13^2+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13(169+1)(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
&=13cdot170(13^2-1)(13^8+13^4+1)\
end{align}$$
Remark: This approach is, of course, more convoluted than the modular approach. (It also relies in part on knowing which terms, such as $12^2+6^2$, will produce a factor of $10$.) If anything, it should demonstrate the value of learning how modular arithmetic works!
edited Nov 25 at 20:57
answered Nov 25 at 19:04
Barry Cipra
58.5k652122
58.5k652122
2
That's surely beyond the OPs exposure to number theory, don't you think?
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:19
@fleablood, the OP only just now added the disclaimer about not having studied modular arithmetic. Before that it was hard to tell what they did or didn't know.
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 19:26
what does OP refer to, stands for??
– Maged Saeed
Nov 25 at 20:07
1
@MagedSaeed, Original Post(er).
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 20:24
@fleablood The 2nd approach above uses only the Factor Theorem so it is likely accessible to the OP. Slightly more streamlined is to use the Binomial Theorem as I do in my answer, but that's still far from the elegance and simplicity of modular arithmetic .
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 25 at 21:30
|
show 2 more comments
2
That's surely beyond the OPs exposure to number theory, don't you think?
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:19
@fleablood, the OP only just now added the disclaimer about not having studied modular arithmetic. Before that it was hard to tell what they did or didn't know.
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 19:26
what does OP refer to, stands for??
– Maged Saeed
Nov 25 at 20:07
1
@MagedSaeed, Original Post(er).
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 20:24
@fleablood The 2nd approach above uses only the Factor Theorem so it is likely accessible to the OP. Slightly more streamlined is to use the Binomial Theorem as I do in my answer, but that's still far from the elegance and simplicity of modular arithmetic .
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 25 at 21:30
2
2
That's surely beyond the OPs exposure to number theory, don't you think?
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:19
That's surely beyond the OPs exposure to number theory, don't you think?
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:19
@fleablood, the OP only just now added the disclaimer about not having studied modular arithmetic. Before that it was hard to tell what they did or didn't know.
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 19:26
@fleablood, the OP only just now added the disclaimer about not having studied modular arithmetic. Before that it was hard to tell what they did or didn't know.
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 19:26
what does OP refer to, stands for??
– Maged Saeed
Nov 25 at 20:07
what does OP refer to, stands for??
– Maged Saeed
Nov 25 at 20:07
1
1
@MagedSaeed, Original Post(er).
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 20:24
@MagedSaeed, Original Post(er).
– Barry Cipra
Nov 25 at 20:24
@fleablood The 2nd approach above uses only the Factor Theorem so it is likely accessible to the OP. Slightly more streamlined is to use the Binomial Theorem as I do in my answer, but that's still far from the elegance and simplicity of modular arithmetic .
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 25 at 21:30
@fleablood The 2nd approach above uses only the Factor Theorem so it is likely accessible to the OP. Slightly more streamlined is to use the Binomial Theorem as I do in my answer, but that's still far from the elegance and simplicity of modular arithmetic .
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 25 at 21:30
|
show 2 more comments
up vote
0
down vote
You might be able to show that the units digit is zero pretty easily.
This is the shortest and most to the point answer!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:01
If MPW provides an example or some steps to show that the units digit is zero, then it will be much appreciated.
– 乇乂ㄒ尺卂ㄒ卄丨匚匚
Nov 25 at 19:06
Well, the trick is to realize that the last digit of $n^k$ is the same as the last digit of the last digit of $n$ to the $k$. So the last digit of $11^{11}$ is the same as the last digit of $1^{11} = 1$ and the last digit of $12^{12}$ is the same as the last digit of $2^{12}$ and the last digit of $13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $3^{13}$. Now you might think finding out the last digit of $3^{13}$ is hard but if we "throw away" every thing but the last digit is easy: $3^2=9; 3^3=9*3=27=7; 3^4=7*3=21=1;3^5=1*3=3;3^6=3*3=9;3^7=9*3=27=7...$ etc. notice that last digit of $3^4$ is $1$.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:16
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
You might be able to show that the units digit is zero pretty easily.
This is the shortest and most to the point answer!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:01
If MPW provides an example or some steps to show that the units digit is zero, then it will be much appreciated.
– 乇乂ㄒ尺卂ㄒ卄丨匚匚
Nov 25 at 19:06
Well, the trick is to realize that the last digit of $n^k$ is the same as the last digit of the last digit of $n$ to the $k$. So the last digit of $11^{11}$ is the same as the last digit of $1^{11} = 1$ and the last digit of $12^{12}$ is the same as the last digit of $2^{12}$ and the last digit of $13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $3^{13}$. Now you might think finding out the last digit of $3^{13}$ is hard but if we "throw away" every thing but the last digit is easy: $3^2=9; 3^3=9*3=27=7; 3^4=7*3=21=1;3^5=1*3=3;3^6=3*3=9;3^7=9*3=27=7...$ etc. notice that last digit of $3^4$ is $1$.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:16
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
You might be able to show that the units digit is zero pretty easily.
You might be able to show that the units digit is zero pretty easily.
answered Nov 25 at 18:54
MPW
29.7k11956
29.7k11956
This is the shortest and most to the point answer!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:01
If MPW provides an example or some steps to show that the units digit is zero, then it will be much appreciated.
– 乇乂ㄒ尺卂ㄒ卄丨匚匚
Nov 25 at 19:06
Well, the trick is to realize that the last digit of $n^k$ is the same as the last digit of the last digit of $n$ to the $k$. So the last digit of $11^{11}$ is the same as the last digit of $1^{11} = 1$ and the last digit of $12^{12}$ is the same as the last digit of $2^{12}$ and the last digit of $13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $3^{13}$. Now you might think finding out the last digit of $3^{13}$ is hard but if we "throw away" every thing but the last digit is easy: $3^2=9; 3^3=9*3=27=7; 3^4=7*3=21=1;3^5=1*3=3;3^6=3*3=9;3^7=9*3=27=7...$ etc. notice that last digit of $3^4$ is $1$.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:16
add a comment |
This is the shortest and most to the point answer!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:01
If MPW provides an example or some steps to show that the units digit is zero, then it will be much appreciated.
– 乇乂ㄒ尺卂ㄒ卄丨匚匚
Nov 25 at 19:06
Well, the trick is to realize that the last digit of $n^k$ is the same as the last digit of the last digit of $n$ to the $k$. So the last digit of $11^{11}$ is the same as the last digit of $1^{11} = 1$ and the last digit of $12^{12}$ is the same as the last digit of $2^{12}$ and the last digit of $13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $3^{13}$. Now you might think finding out the last digit of $3^{13}$ is hard but if we "throw away" every thing but the last digit is easy: $3^2=9; 3^3=9*3=27=7; 3^4=7*3=21=1;3^5=1*3=3;3^6=3*3=9;3^7=9*3=27=7...$ etc. notice that last digit of $3^4$ is $1$.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:16
This is the shortest and most to the point answer!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:01
This is the shortest and most to the point answer!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:01
If MPW provides an example or some steps to show that the units digit is zero, then it will be much appreciated.
– 乇乂ㄒ尺卂ㄒ卄丨匚匚
Nov 25 at 19:06
If MPW provides an example or some steps to show that the units digit is zero, then it will be much appreciated.
– 乇乂ㄒ尺卂ㄒ卄丨匚匚
Nov 25 at 19:06
Well, the trick is to realize that the last digit of $n^k$ is the same as the last digit of the last digit of $n$ to the $k$. So the last digit of $11^{11}$ is the same as the last digit of $1^{11} = 1$ and the last digit of $12^{12}$ is the same as the last digit of $2^{12}$ and the last digit of $13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $3^{13}$. Now you might think finding out the last digit of $3^{13}$ is hard but if we "throw away" every thing but the last digit is easy: $3^2=9; 3^3=9*3=27=7; 3^4=7*3=21=1;3^5=1*3=3;3^6=3*3=9;3^7=9*3=27=7...$ etc. notice that last digit of $3^4$ is $1$.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:16
Well, the trick is to realize that the last digit of $n^k$ is the same as the last digit of the last digit of $n$ to the $k$. So the last digit of $11^{11}$ is the same as the last digit of $1^{11} = 1$ and the last digit of $12^{12}$ is the same as the last digit of $2^{12}$ and the last digit of $13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $3^{13}$. Now you might think finding out the last digit of $3^{13}$ is hard but if we "throw away" every thing but the last digit is easy: $3^2=9; 3^3=9*3=27=7; 3^4=7*3=21=1;3^5=1*3=3;3^6=3*3=9;3^7=9*3=27=7...$ etc. notice that last digit of $3^4$ is $1$.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:16
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Last digit of $11^11$ is obviously 1.
$12^1$ ends at 2. $12^2$ ends at 4. $12^3$ at 8. $12^4$ at 6, and $12^5$ again at 2. So, last digit of $12^{12}$ is 6.
$13^1$ ends at 3. $13^2$ at 9. $13^3$ at 7, $13^4$ ends at 1 and $13^5$ again ends at 3. Hence, $13^{13}$ ends at 3.
Finally, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$$ ends at 0 at your number is divisible by 10.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Last digit of $11^11$ is obviously 1.
$12^1$ ends at 2. $12^2$ ends at 4. $12^3$ at 8. $12^4$ at 6, and $12^5$ again at 2. So, last digit of $12^{12}$ is 6.
$13^1$ ends at 3. $13^2$ at 9. $13^3$ at 7, $13^4$ ends at 1 and $13^5$ again ends at 3. Hence, $13^{13}$ ends at 3.
Finally, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$$ ends at 0 at your number is divisible by 10.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Last digit of $11^11$ is obviously 1.
$12^1$ ends at 2. $12^2$ ends at 4. $12^3$ at 8. $12^4$ at 6, and $12^5$ again at 2. So, last digit of $12^{12}$ is 6.
$13^1$ ends at 3. $13^2$ at 9. $13^3$ at 7, $13^4$ ends at 1 and $13^5$ again ends at 3. Hence, $13^{13}$ ends at 3.
Finally, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$$ ends at 0 at your number is divisible by 10.
Last digit of $11^11$ is obviously 1.
$12^1$ ends at 2. $12^2$ ends at 4. $12^3$ at 8. $12^4$ at 6, and $12^5$ again at 2. So, last digit of $12^{12}$ is 6.
$13^1$ ends at 3. $13^2$ at 9. $13^3$ at 7, $13^4$ ends at 1 and $13^5$ again ends at 3. Hence, $13^{13}$ ends at 3.
Finally, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$$ ends at 0 at your number is divisible by 10.
answered Nov 25 at 18:56
Tito Eliatron
1,317622
1,317622
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Simple calculation :
$11 equiv 1 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $11^{11} equiv 1 (mod 10)$
$12 equiv 2 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $12^{12} equiv 6 (mod 10)$
$13 equiv 3 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $13^{13} equiv 3 (mod 10)$
Hence
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv 1+6+3 equiv 0 (mod 10)$
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Simple calculation :
$11 equiv 1 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $11^{11} equiv 1 (mod 10)$
$12 equiv 2 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $12^{12} equiv 6 (mod 10)$
$13 equiv 3 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $13^{13} equiv 3 (mod 10)$
Hence
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv 1+6+3 equiv 0 (mod 10)$
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Simple calculation :
$11 equiv 1 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $11^{11} equiv 1 (mod 10)$
$12 equiv 2 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $12^{12} equiv 6 (mod 10)$
$13 equiv 3 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $13^{13} equiv 3 (mod 10)$
Hence
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv 1+6+3 equiv 0 (mod 10)$
Simple calculation :
$11 equiv 1 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $11^{11} equiv 1 (mod 10)$
$12 equiv 2 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $12^{12} equiv 6 (mod 10)$
$13 equiv 3 (mod 10)$ $implies$ $13^{13} equiv 3 (mod 10)$
Hence
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv 1+6+3 equiv 0 (mod 10)$
answered Nov 25 at 18:59
Anik Bhowmick
578417
578417
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
The final digit of $11^{11}$ is easy. If we are able to use Fermat-Euler we have that $varphi (10)=4$ so that if $n$ is coprime to $10$ then $n^4equiv 1$ and that applies with $n=3$ so that $13^{13}equiv 3^{12}cdot 3equiv 3 bmod 10$.
$12$ is more interesting - we can't use the coprime property. The exponent is small enough that you can do it by hand, but here is another trick (working modulo $10$).
First $12^{12}equiv 2^{12}$
Then $12^{12}=3^{12}cdot 4^{12}equiv left(2^{12}right)^2$ (we did $3^{12}equiv 1$ already)
Let $2^{12}equiv m$, then $m^2equiv m$ from the two calculations above, and $m$ is even and non-zero, so must be $6$.
I added this because it is interesting, and very occasionally such alternative ways of working save a lot of time.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
The final digit of $11^{11}$ is easy. If we are able to use Fermat-Euler we have that $varphi (10)=4$ so that if $n$ is coprime to $10$ then $n^4equiv 1$ and that applies with $n=3$ so that $13^{13}equiv 3^{12}cdot 3equiv 3 bmod 10$.
$12$ is more interesting - we can't use the coprime property. The exponent is small enough that you can do it by hand, but here is another trick (working modulo $10$).
First $12^{12}equiv 2^{12}$
Then $12^{12}=3^{12}cdot 4^{12}equiv left(2^{12}right)^2$ (we did $3^{12}equiv 1$ already)
Let $2^{12}equiv m$, then $m^2equiv m$ from the two calculations above, and $m$ is even and non-zero, so must be $6$.
I added this because it is interesting, and very occasionally such alternative ways of working save a lot of time.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
The final digit of $11^{11}$ is easy. If we are able to use Fermat-Euler we have that $varphi (10)=4$ so that if $n$ is coprime to $10$ then $n^4equiv 1$ and that applies with $n=3$ so that $13^{13}equiv 3^{12}cdot 3equiv 3 bmod 10$.
$12$ is more interesting - we can't use the coprime property. The exponent is small enough that you can do it by hand, but here is another trick (working modulo $10$).
First $12^{12}equiv 2^{12}$
Then $12^{12}=3^{12}cdot 4^{12}equiv left(2^{12}right)^2$ (we did $3^{12}equiv 1$ already)
Let $2^{12}equiv m$, then $m^2equiv m$ from the two calculations above, and $m$ is even and non-zero, so must be $6$.
I added this because it is interesting, and very occasionally such alternative ways of working save a lot of time.
The final digit of $11^{11}$ is easy. If we are able to use Fermat-Euler we have that $varphi (10)=4$ so that if $n$ is coprime to $10$ then $n^4equiv 1$ and that applies with $n=3$ so that $13^{13}equiv 3^{12}cdot 3equiv 3 bmod 10$.
$12$ is more interesting - we can't use the coprime property. The exponent is small enough that you can do it by hand, but here is another trick (working modulo $10$).
First $12^{12}equiv 2^{12}$
Then $12^{12}=3^{12}cdot 4^{12}equiv left(2^{12}right)^2$ (we did $3^{12}equiv 1$ already)
Let $2^{12}equiv m$, then $m^2equiv m$ from the two calculations above, and $m$ is even and non-zero, so must be $6$.
I added this because it is interesting, and very occasionally such alternative ways of working save a lot of time.
answered Nov 25 at 19:12
Mark Bennet
80k980178
80k980178
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
You can easily prove it without any modular arithmetic. Just look at the last digits.
$$3^1 = color{blue}{3} quad 3^2 = color{blue}{9} quad 3^3 = 2color{blue}{7} quad 3^4 = 8color{blue}{1} implies 3, 9, 7, 1, 3, 9, 7, 1, ...$$
$$2^1 = color{green}{2} quad 2^2 = color{green}{4} quad 2^3 = color{green}{8} quad 2^4 = 1color{green}{6} implies 2, 4, 8, 6, 2, 4, 8, 6, ...$$
The pattern loops every $4^{th}$ exponent, as you can see. Notice that $13^{13}$ must end with whatever $3^{13}$ ends with, and $2^{12}$ must end with whatever $2^{12}$ ends with.
$$13 = color{purple}{3}(4)+color{blue}{1} quadtext{Three loops done; first exponent}$$
$$12 = color{purple}{2}(4)+color{green}{4} quadtext{Two loops done; fourth exponent}$$
Thus, $13^{13}$ ends with $color{blue}{3}$ and $12^{12}$ ends with $color{green}{6}$. $11^{11}$ obviously ends with $1$, so what does the unit digit become?
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
You can easily prove it without any modular arithmetic. Just look at the last digits.
$$3^1 = color{blue}{3} quad 3^2 = color{blue}{9} quad 3^3 = 2color{blue}{7} quad 3^4 = 8color{blue}{1} implies 3, 9, 7, 1, 3, 9, 7, 1, ...$$
$$2^1 = color{green}{2} quad 2^2 = color{green}{4} quad 2^3 = color{green}{8} quad 2^4 = 1color{green}{6} implies 2, 4, 8, 6, 2, 4, 8, 6, ...$$
The pattern loops every $4^{th}$ exponent, as you can see. Notice that $13^{13}$ must end with whatever $3^{13}$ ends with, and $2^{12}$ must end with whatever $2^{12}$ ends with.
$$13 = color{purple}{3}(4)+color{blue}{1} quadtext{Three loops done; first exponent}$$
$$12 = color{purple}{2}(4)+color{green}{4} quadtext{Two loops done; fourth exponent}$$
Thus, $13^{13}$ ends with $color{blue}{3}$ and $12^{12}$ ends with $color{green}{6}$. $11^{11}$ obviously ends with $1$, so what does the unit digit become?
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
You can easily prove it without any modular arithmetic. Just look at the last digits.
$$3^1 = color{blue}{3} quad 3^2 = color{blue}{9} quad 3^3 = 2color{blue}{7} quad 3^4 = 8color{blue}{1} implies 3, 9, 7, 1, 3, 9, 7, 1, ...$$
$$2^1 = color{green}{2} quad 2^2 = color{green}{4} quad 2^3 = color{green}{8} quad 2^4 = 1color{green}{6} implies 2, 4, 8, 6, 2, 4, 8, 6, ...$$
The pattern loops every $4^{th}$ exponent, as you can see. Notice that $13^{13}$ must end with whatever $3^{13}$ ends with, and $2^{12}$ must end with whatever $2^{12}$ ends with.
$$13 = color{purple}{3}(4)+color{blue}{1} quadtext{Three loops done; first exponent}$$
$$12 = color{purple}{2}(4)+color{green}{4} quadtext{Two loops done; fourth exponent}$$
Thus, $13^{13}$ ends with $color{blue}{3}$ and $12^{12}$ ends with $color{green}{6}$. $11^{11}$ obviously ends with $1$, so what does the unit digit become?
You can easily prove it without any modular arithmetic. Just look at the last digits.
$$3^1 = color{blue}{3} quad 3^2 = color{blue}{9} quad 3^3 = 2color{blue}{7} quad 3^4 = 8color{blue}{1} implies 3, 9, 7, 1, 3, 9, 7, 1, ...$$
$$2^1 = color{green}{2} quad 2^2 = color{green}{4} quad 2^3 = color{green}{8} quad 2^4 = 1color{green}{6} implies 2, 4, 8, 6, 2, 4, 8, 6, ...$$
The pattern loops every $4^{th}$ exponent, as you can see. Notice that $13^{13}$ must end with whatever $3^{13}$ ends with, and $2^{12}$ must end with whatever $2^{12}$ ends with.
$$13 = color{purple}{3}(4)+color{blue}{1} quadtext{Three loops done; first exponent}$$
$$12 = color{purple}{2}(4)+color{green}{4} quadtext{Two loops done; fourth exponent}$$
Thus, $13^{13}$ ends with $color{blue}{3}$ and $12^{12}$ ends with $color{green}{6}$. $11^{11}$ obviously ends with $1$, so what does the unit digit become?
edited Nov 25 at 19:53
answered Nov 25 at 19:26
KM101
3,416417
3,416417
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Tedious the first time you do it way but once you do it is obvious:
$$11^{11} = (10 + 1)^{11} = 10^{11} + 11*10^{10} + 55*10^9..... + 55*10^2 + 11*10 + 1 = 10M + 1$$ for $M= 10^{10} + 11*10^{9} + 55*10^8..... + 55*10 + 11$. But ... THE EXACT VALUE OF $M$ WILL NOT MATTER!!!... The only thing that matters is the remander $1$.
Likewise $$12^{12} = (10 + 2)^{12} = 10^{12} + 12*2*10^{11} + 66*2^2*10^{10} + .... . + 66*2^{10}*10^2+ 12*2^{11}*10 + 2^{12} = 10N + 2^{12}$$ for $N = 10^{12} + .... text{oh, what that hell do we care}$.
And $$13^{13} = (10+3)^{13} = 10^{13} + 13*10^{12}*3 + ..... +13*10*3^{12} + 3^{12} = 10K + 3^{13}$$ for $K = text{whatever}$.
So $$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13} = 10N + 10M + 10K + 1 + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$. But since we are only interested in whether it is divisible by $10$ we can ignore the $10N + 10M + 10K$ because it is divisible by $10$.
So for all that tedious work we've come up with the simple and useful idea that "if we want to find out if something is divisible by $10$ we only have to do math on the remainders. We could have done that in our heads!
If $equiv_{10}$ means "has the same remainder when divided by $10$" we could have done that in one line:
$$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}equiv_{10} 1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$
$1^{11} = 1$ of course.
And we can do $2^{12}$ in steps.
$2^2 = 4; 2^4= 4^2 = 16=10+6equiv_{10} 6$.
$2^8 = (10 + 6)^2 = 100 + 2*6*10 + 36= 10M + 6equiv{10} 6$.
So $2^{12} = 2^8*2^4 = (10M + 6)(10 +6) =100M + 6*10 + 10*6M + 6*6equiv_{10}6*6=36equiv_{10} 6$.
At this point we should realize we can just go deirectly to working with remainders.
$3^{2} = 9; 3^4 = 9^2 = 81 equiv_{10} 1$. So $3^{13}3^4*3^4*3^4*3equiv_{10} 1*1*1*3=3$.
So if we had used this concept of remainders from the begining we'd have done it in two or three lines:
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1 + (2^4)^3 +(3^4)^3 times 3 equiv_{10}$
$1 + 16^3 + 81^3*3 equiv $
$1 +6^3 + 1^3*3equiv $
$1 + 36*6 + 3 equiv $
$1 + 6*6 + 3equiv $
$1 + 36 + 3equiv $
$1 + 6 + 3equiv 10 equiv 0$.
So $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ has remainder $0$ when divided by $10$ which is to say $11^11 + 12^{12} +13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
====
A number is devisible by $10$ if and only if the last digit is $0$.
And value of the last digits arithmetically "distribute". That is if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ then the last digit of $n^k$ is the last digit of $a^k$. (Because $n = 10b +a$ so $n^k =(10b + a)^k = abunchofmultiplesof(10) + a^k$) and if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ and the last digit of $m$ is $c$ then the last digit of $m + n$ is the last digit of $b+1$ and the last digit of $mtimes n$ is the last digit of $btimes c$.
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$ if only if its last digit is $0$.
And the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the last digit of $1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}$
$1^{11} = 1$.
$2^{12} = 2^4times 2^4 times 2^4 = 16times 16times 16$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6times 6$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6=36$ so the last digit is $6$.
$3^{13} = 3^4times 3^4 times 3^4 times 3$. $3^4 = 81$ so the last digit of $3^{13}$ is the last digit of $1times1times 1times 3 = 3$>
So the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $1 + 6 + 3 =10$. And that digit is $0$.
So, yes, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Tedious the first time you do it way but once you do it is obvious:
$$11^{11} = (10 + 1)^{11} = 10^{11} + 11*10^{10} + 55*10^9..... + 55*10^2 + 11*10 + 1 = 10M + 1$$ for $M= 10^{10} + 11*10^{9} + 55*10^8..... + 55*10 + 11$. But ... THE EXACT VALUE OF $M$ WILL NOT MATTER!!!... The only thing that matters is the remander $1$.
Likewise $$12^{12} = (10 + 2)^{12} = 10^{12} + 12*2*10^{11} + 66*2^2*10^{10} + .... . + 66*2^{10}*10^2+ 12*2^{11}*10 + 2^{12} = 10N + 2^{12}$$ for $N = 10^{12} + .... text{oh, what that hell do we care}$.
And $$13^{13} = (10+3)^{13} = 10^{13} + 13*10^{12}*3 + ..... +13*10*3^{12} + 3^{12} = 10K + 3^{13}$$ for $K = text{whatever}$.
So $$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13} = 10N + 10M + 10K + 1 + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$. But since we are only interested in whether it is divisible by $10$ we can ignore the $10N + 10M + 10K$ because it is divisible by $10$.
So for all that tedious work we've come up with the simple and useful idea that "if we want to find out if something is divisible by $10$ we only have to do math on the remainders. We could have done that in our heads!
If $equiv_{10}$ means "has the same remainder when divided by $10$" we could have done that in one line:
$$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}equiv_{10} 1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$
$1^{11} = 1$ of course.
And we can do $2^{12}$ in steps.
$2^2 = 4; 2^4= 4^2 = 16=10+6equiv_{10} 6$.
$2^8 = (10 + 6)^2 = 100 + 2*6*10 + 36= 10M + 6equiv{10} 6$.
So $2^{12} = 2^8*2^4 = (10M + 6)(10 +6) =100M + 6*10 + 10*6M + 6*6equiv_{10}6*6=36equiv_{10} 6$.
At this point we should realize we can just go deirectly to working with remainders.
$3^{2} = 9; 3^4 = 9^2 = 81 equiv_{10} 1$. So $3^{13}3^4*3^4*3^4*3equiv_{10} 1*1*1*3=3$.
So if we had used this concept of remainders from the begining we'd have done it in two or three lines:
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1 + (2^4)^3 +(3^4)^3 times 3 equiv_{10}$
$1 + 16^3 + 81^3*3 equiv $
$1 +6^3 + 1^3*3equiv $
$1 + 36*6 + 3 equiv $
$1 + 6*6 + 3equiv $
$1 + 36 + 3equiv $
$1 + 6 + 3equiv 10 equiv 0$.
So $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ has remainder $0$ when divided by $10$ which is to say $11^11 + 12^{12} +13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
====
A number is devisible by $10$ if and only if the last digit is $0$.
And value of the last digits arithmetically "distribute". That is if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ then the last digit of $n^k$ is the last digit of $a^k$. (Because $n = 10b +a$ so $n^k =(10b + a)^k = abunchofmultiplesof(10) + a^k$) and if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ and the last digit of $m$ is $c$ then the last digit of $m + n$ is the last digit of $b+1$ and the last digit of $mtimes n$ is the last digit of $btimes c$.
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$ if only if its last digit is $0$.
And the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the last digit of $1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}$
$1^{11} = 1$.
$2^{12} = 2^4times 2^4 times 2^4 = 16times 16times 16$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6times 6$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6=36$ so the last digit is $6$.
$3^{13} = 3^4times 3^4 times 3^4 times 3$. $3^4 = 81$ so the last digit of $3^{13}$ is the last digit of $1times1times 1times 3 = 3$>
So the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $1 + 6 + 3 =10$. And that digit is $0$.
So, yes, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Tedious the first time you do it way but once you do it is obvious:
$$11^{11} = (10 + 1)^{11} = 10^{11} + 11*10^{10} + 55*10^9..... + 55*10^2 + 11*10 + 1 = 10M + 1$$ for $M= 10^{10} + 11*10^{9} + 55*10^8..... + 55*10 + 11$. But ... THE EXACT VALUE OF $M$ WILL NOT MATTER!!!... The only thing that matters is the remander $1$.
Likewise $$12^{12} = (10 + 2)^{12} = 10^{12} + 12*2*10^{11} + 66*2^2*10^{10} + .... . + 66*2^{10}*10^2+ 12*2^{11}*10 + 2^{12} = 10N + 2^{12}$$ for $N = 10^{12} + .... text{oh, what that hell do we care}$.
And $$13^{13} = (10+3)^{13} = 10^{13} + 13*10^{12}*3 + ..... +13*10*3^{12} + 3^{12} = 10K + 3^{13}$$ for $K = text{whatever}$.
So $$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13} = 10N + 10M + 10K + 1 + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$. But since we are only interested in whether it is divisible by $10$ we can ignore the $10N + 10M + 10K$ because it is divisible by $10$.
So for all that tedious work we've come up with the simple and useful idea that "if we want to find out if something is divisible by $10$ we only have to do math on the remainders. We could have done that in our heads!
If $equiv_{10}$ means "has the same remainder when divided by $10$" we could have done that in one line:
$$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}equiv_{10} 1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$
$1^{11} = 1$ of course.
And we can do $2^{12}$ in steps.
$2^2 = 4; 2^4= 4^2 = 16=10+6equiv_{10} 6$.
$2^8 = (10 + 6)^2 = 100 + 2*6*10 + 36= 10M + 6equiv{10} 6$.
So $2^{12} = 2^8*2^4 = (10M + 6)(10 +6) =100M + 6*10 + 10*6M + 6*6equiv_{10}6*6=36equiv_{10} 6$.
At this point we should realize we can just go deirectly to working with remainders.
$3^{2} = 9; 3^4 = 9^2 = 81 equiv_{10} 1$. So $3^{13}3^4*3^4*3^4*3equiv_{10} 1*1*1*3=3$.
So if we had used this concept of remainders from the begining we'd have done it in two or three lines:
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1 + (2^4)^3 +(3^4)^3 times 3 equiv_{10}$
$1 + 16^3 + 81^3*3 equiv $
$1 +6^3 + 1^3*3equiv $
$1 + 36*6 + 3 equiv $
$1 + 6*6 + 3equiv $
$1 + 36 + 3equiv $
$1 + 6 + 3equiv 10 equiv 0$.
So $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ has remainder $0$ when divided by $10$ which is to say $11^11 + 12^{12} +13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
====
A number is devisible by $10$ if and only if the last digit is $0$.
And value of the last digits arithmetically "distribute". That is if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ then the last digit of $n^k$ is the last digit of $a^k$. (Because $n = 10b +a$ so $n^k =(10b + a)^k = abunchofmultiplesof(10) + a^k$) and if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ and the last digit of $m$ is $c$ then the last digit of $m + n$ is the last digit of $b+1$ and the last digit of $mtimes n$ is the last digit of $btimes c$.
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$ if only if its last digit is $0$.
And the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the last digit of $1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}$
$1^{11} = 1$.
$2^{12} = 2^4times 2^4 times 2^4 = 16times 16times 16$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6times 6$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6=36$ so the last digit is $6$.
$3^{13} = 3^4times 3^4 times 3^4 times 3$. $3^4 = 81$ so the last digit of $3^{13}$ is the last digit of $1times1times 1times 3 = 3$>
So the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $1 + 6 + 3 =10$. And that digit is $0$.
So, yes, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
Tedious the first time you do it way but once you do it is obvious:
$$11^{11} = (10 + 1)^{11} = 10^{11} + 11*10^{10} + 55*10^9..... + 55*10^2 + 11*10 + 1 = 10M + 1$$ for $M= 10^{10} + 11*10^{9} + 55*10^8..... + 55*10 + 11$. But ... THE EXACT VALUE OF $M$ WILL NOT MATTER!!!... The only thing that matters is the remander $1$.
Likewise $$12^{12} = (10 + 2)^{12} = 10^{12} + 12*2*10^{11} + 66*2^2*10^{10} + .... . + 66*2^{10}*10^2+ 12*2^{11}*10 + 2^{12} = 10N + 2^{12}$$ for $N = 10^{12} + .... text{oh, what that hell do we care}$.
And $$13^{13} = (10+3)^{13} = 10^{13} + 13*10^{12}*3 + ..... +13*10*3^{12} + 3^{12} = 10K + 3^{13}$$ for $K = text{whatever}$.
So $$11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13} = 10N + 10M + 10K + 1 + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$. But since we are only interested in whether it is divisible by $10$ we can ignore the $10N + 10M + 10K$ because it is divisible by $10$.
So for all that tedious work we've come up with the simple and useful idea that "if we want to find out if something is divisible by $10$ we only have to do math on the remainders. We could have done that in our heads!
If $equiv_{10}$ means "has the same remainder when divided by $10$" we could have done that in one line:
$$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}equiv_{10} 1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13}$$
$1^{11} = 1$ of course.
And we can do $2^{12}$ in steps.
$2^2 = 4; 2^4= 4^2 = 16=10+6equiv_{10} 6$.
$2^8 = (10 + 6)^2 = 100 + 2*6*10 + 36= 10M + 6equiv{10} 6$.
So $2^{12} = 2^8*2^4 = (10M + 6)(10 +6) =100M + 6*10 + 10*6M + 6*6equiv_{10}6*6=36equiv_{10} 6$.
At this point we should realize we can just go deirectly to working with remainders.
$3^{2} = 9; 3^4 = 9^2 = 81 equiv_{10} 1$. So $3^{13}3^4*3^4*3^4*3equiv_{10} 1*1*1*3=3$.
So if we had used this concept of remainders from the begining we'd have done it in two or three lines:
$11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1^{11} + 2^{12} + 3^{13} equiv_{10}$
$1 + (2^4)^3 +(3^4)^3 times 3 equiv_{10}$
$1 + 16^3 + 81^3*3 equiv $
$1 +6^3 + 1^3*3equiv $
$1 + 36*6 + 3 equiv $
$1 + 6*6 + 3equiv $
$1 + 36 + 3equiv $
$1 + 6 + 3equiv 10 equiv 0$.
So $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ has remainder $0$ when divided by $10$ which is to say $11^11 + 12^{12} +13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
====
A number is devisible by $10$ if and only if the last digit is $0$.
And value of the last digits arithmetically "distribute". That is if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ then the last digit of $n^k$ is the last digit of $a^k$. (Because $n = 10b +a$ so $n^k =(10b + a)^k = abunchofmultiplesof(10) + a^k$) and if the last digit of $n$ is $a$ and the last digit of $m$ is $c$ then the last digit of $m + n$ is the last digit of $b+1$ and the last digit of $mtimes n$ is the last digit of $btimes c$.
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$ if only if its last digit is $0$.
And the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the last digit of $1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}$
$1^{11} = 1$.
$2^{12} = 2^4times 2^4 times 2^4 = 16times 16times 16$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6times 6$ so the last digit is the same as $6times 6=36$ so the last digit is $6$.
$3^{13} = 3^4times 3^4 times 3^4 times 3$. $3^4 = 81$ so the last digit of $3^{13}$ is the last digit of $1times1times 1times 3 = 3$>
So the last digit of $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is the same as the last digit of $1 + 6 + 3 =10$. And that digit is $0$.
So, yes, $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by $10$.
edited Nov 25 at 22:26
answered Nov 25 at 18:58
fleablood
66.9k22684
66.9k22684
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Since you don't know modular arithmetic we can instead employ the Binomial Theorem.
Theorem $ 10 $ divides $ (1!+!10a)^{large k}!+ (2!+!10b)^{large 4n}!+(3!+!10c)^{large 1+4n} $ for $,a,b,cinBbb Z, k,nin Bbb N$
Proof $ $ To show it's divisible by $10$ it suffices to show it's divisible by $,2,$ and $,5,$. Notice it has parity odd + even + odd = even, so $,2,$ divides it. Below we show that $,5,$ divides it too.
Note that $ (x,+,color{#c00}5y)^{large m}, =, x^{large m}, +, color{#c00}5(cdots) ,$ by $ rmcolor{#0a0}{BT}$ := Binomial Theorem, for $(cdots)$ an integer.
$!!begin{align} {rm Therefore},
(2+10b)^{large 4n} &= 2^{large 4n},+, 5,i, , text{for an integer } i, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\[.2em]
&= (1!+!15)^{large n}! + 5,i\[,2em]
&= 1 + 5,j, +, 5,i, text{for an integer } j, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\
end{align}$
Similarly $, (1+10a)^{large k} =, 1 + 5,d$
and also $ (3+10c)^{large 1+4n}! = 3 + 5,e$
Therefore their sum equals $: 1 + 1 + 3 + 5(cdots) = $ multiple of $5. $ QED
Alternatively we can replace the Binomial Theorem by the Factor Theorem as follows $$large z^m!-x^m = (z!-!x)(cdots) {rm for} z=x!+!5y, {rm has factor} z-x = color{#c00}5y {rm so is divisible by}, color{#c00}5quad$$ This method is used in Barry's answer. $ $
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 26 at 2:34
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Since you don't know modular arithmetic we can instead employ the Binomial Theorem.
Theorem $ 10 $ divides $ (1!+!10a)^{large k}!+ (2!+!10b)^{large 4n}!+(3!+!10c)^{large 1+4n} $ for $,a,b,cinBbb Z, k,nin Bbb N$
Proof $ $ To show it's divisible by $10$ it suffices to show it's divisible by $,2,$ and $,5,$. Notice it has parity odd + even + odd = even, so $,2,$ divides it. Below we show that $,5,$ divides it too.
Note that $ (x,+,color{#c00}5y)^{large m}, =, x^{large m}, +, color{#c00}5(cdots) ,$ by $ rmcolor{#0a0}{BT}$ := Binomial Theorem, for $(cdots)$ an integer.
$!!begin{align} {rm Therefore},
(2+10b)^{large 4n} &= 2^{large 4n},+, 5,i, , text{for an integer } i, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\[.2em]
&= (1!+!15)^{large n}! + 5,i\[,2em]
&= 1 + 5,j, +, 5,i, text{for an integer } j, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\
end{align}$
Similarly $, (1+10a)^{large k} =, 1 + 5,d$
and also $ (3+10c)^{large 1+4n}! = 3 + 5,e$
Therefore their sum equals $: 1 + 1 + 3 + 5(cdots) = $ multiple of $5. $ QED
Alternatively we can replace the Binomial Theorem by the Factor Theorem as follows $$large z^m!-x^m = (z!-!x)(cdots) {rm for} z=x!+!5y, {rm has factor} z-x = color{#c00}5y {rm so is divisible by}, color{#c00}5quad$$ This method is used in Barry's answer. $ $
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 26 at 2:34
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Since you don't know modular arithmetic we can instead employ the Binomial Theorem.
Theorem $ 10 $ divides $ (1!+!10a)^{large k}!+ (2!+!10b)^{large 4n}!+(3!+!10c)^{large 1+4n} $ for $,a,b,cinBbb Z, k,nin Bbb N$
Proof $ $ To show it's divisible by $10$ it suffices to show it's divisible by $,2,$ and $,5,$. Notice it has parity odd + even + odd = even, so $,2,$ divides it. Below we show that $,5,$ divides it too.
Note that $ (x,+,color{#c00}5y)^{large m}, =, x^{large m}, +, color{#c00}5(cdots) ,$ by $ rmcolor{#0a0}{BT}$ := Binomial Theorem, for $(cdots)$ an integer.
$!!begin{align} {rm Therefore},
(2+10b)^{large 4n} &= 2^{large 4n},+, 5,i, , text{for an integer } i, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\[.2em]
&= (1!+!15)^{large n}! + 5,i\[,2em]
&= 1 + 5,j, +, 5,i, text{for an integer } j, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\
end{align}$
Similarly $, (1+10a)^{large k} =, 1 + 5,d$
and also $ (3+10c)^{large 1+4n}! = 3 + 5,e$
Therefore their sum equals $: 1 + 1 + 3 + 5(cdots) = $ multiple of $5. $ QED
Since you don't know modular arithmetic we can instead employ the Binomial Theorem.
Theorem $ 10 $ divides $ (1!+!10a)^{large k}!+ (2!+!10b)^{large 4n}!+(3!+!10c)^{large 1+4n} $ for $,a,b,cinBbb Z, k,nin Bbb N$
Proof $ $ To show it's divisible by $10$ it suffices to show it's divisible by $,2,$ and $,5,$. Notice it has parity odd + even + odd = even, so $,2,$ divides it. Below we show that $,5,$ divides it too.
Note that $ (x,+,color{#c00}5y)^{large m}, =, x^{large m}, +, color{#c00}5(cdots) ,$ by $ rmcolor{#0a0}{BT}$ := Binomial Theorem, for $(cdots)$ an integer.
$!!begin{align} {rm Therefore},
(2+10b)^{large 4n} &= 2^{large 4n},+, 5,i, , text{for an integer } i, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\[.2em]
&= (1!+!15)^{large n}! + 5,i\[,2em]
&= 1 + 5,j, +, 5,i, text{for an integer } j, text{by } rmcolor{#0a0}{BT} as above\
end{align}$
Similarly $, (1+10a)^{large k} =, 1 + 5,d$
and also $ (3+10c)^{large 1+4n}! = 3 + 5,e$
Therefore their sum equals $: 1 + 1 + 3 + 5(cdots) = $ multiple of $5. $ QED
edited Nov 26 at 2:17
answered Nov 25 at 21:13
Bill Dubuque
207k29189624
207k29189624
Alternatively we can replace the Binomial Theorem by the Factor Theorem as follows $$large z^m!-x^m = (z!-!x)(cdots) {rm for} z=x!+!5y, {rm has factor} z-x = color{#c00}5y {rm so is divisible by}, color{#c00}5quad$$ This method is used in Barry's answer. $ $
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 26 at 2:34
add a comment |
Alternatively we can replace the Binomial Theorem by the Factor Theorem as follows $$large z^m!-x^m = (z!-!x)(cdots) {rm for} z=x!+!5y, {rm has factor} z-x = color{#c00}5y {rm so is divisible by}, color{#c00}5quad$$ This method is used in Barry's answer. $ $
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 26 at 2:34
Alternatively we can replace the Binomial Theorem by the Factor Theorem as follows $$large z^m!-x^m = (z!-!x)(cdots) {rm for} z=x!+!5y, {rm has factor} z-x = color{#c00}5y {rm so is divisible by}, color{#c00}5quad$$ This method is used in Barry's answer. $ $
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 26 at 2:34
Alternatively we can replace the Binomial Theorem by the Factor Theorem as follows $$large z^m!-x^m = (z!-!x)(cdots) {rm for} z=x!+!5y, {rm has factor} z-x = color{#c00}5y {rm so is divisible by}, color{#c00}5quad$$ This method is used in Barry's answer. $ $
– Bill Dubuque
Nov 26 at 2:34
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
The first digit of $11^{11}=$ the first digit of $1^{11}=$ $1$.
The first digit of $12^5$ equals the first digit of $2^5=$ the first digit of $32=2$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{10}) =$ (The first digit of $12^5)^2 = 4$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{12}) =
$ (The first digit of $12^{10}) times($The first digit of $12^2) = 6$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{4}) =$ (The first digit of $3^4) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{12}) =$ (The first digit of $(13^4)^3) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{13}) =$ (The first digit of $13^{12} times 3) = 3$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}) =$
(The first digit of $1+6+3) = 0$ }$.
Hence $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
The first digit of $11^{11}=$ the first digit of $1^{11}=$ $1$.
The first digit of $12^5$ equals the first digit of $2^5=$ the first digit of $32=2$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{10}) =$ (The first digit of $12^5)^2 = 4$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{12}) =
$ (The first digit of $12^{10}) times($The first digit of $12^2) = 6$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{4}) =$ (The first digit of $3^4) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{12}) =$ (The first digit of $(13^4)^3) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{13}) =$ (The first digit of $13^{12} times 3) = 3$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}) =$
(The first digit of $1+6+3) = 0$ }$.
Hence $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
The first digit of $11^{11}=$ the first digit of $1^{11}=$ $1$.
The first digit of $12^5$ equals the first digit of $2^5=$ the first digit of $32=2$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{10}) =$ (The first digit of $12^5)^2 = 4$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{12}) =
$ (The first digit of $12^{10}) times($The first digit of $12^2) = 6$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{4}) =$ (The first digit of $3^4) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{12}) =$ (The first digit of $(13^4)^3) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{13}) =$ (The first digit of $13^{12} times 3) = 3$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}) =$
(The first digit of $1+6+3) = 0$ }$.
Hence $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$
The first digit of $11^{11}=$ the first digit of $1^{11}=$ $1$.
The first digit of $12^5$ equals the first digit of $2^5=$ the first digit of $32=2$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{10}) =$ (The first digit of $12^5)^2 = 4$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $12^{12}) =
$ (The first digit of $12^{10}) times($The first digit of $12^2) = 6$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{4}) =$ (The first digit of $3^4) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{12}) =$ (The first digit of $(13^4)^3) = 1$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $13^{13}) =$ (The first digit of $13^{12} times 3) = 3$ }$.
$text{(The first digit of $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}) =$
(The first digit of $1+6+3) = 0$ }$.
Hence $11^{11} + 12^{12} + 13^{13}$ is a multiple of $10$
answered Nov 26 at 6:53
steven gregory
17.6k32257
17.6k32257
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Note that $$11equiv1;mathtt{mod}(10) Rightarrow {11^{11}}equiv {1^{11}}equiv1 ;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Analugously $${12^{12}}equiv{2^{12}}equiv{(2^6)^2}equiv{64^2}equiv6;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$${13^{13}}equiv{(13^4)^2}*13equiv{1^2}*3equiv3; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Thus
$${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}equiv1+6+3equiv 0; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$$therefore10mid bigl({11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}bigr)$$
You can alternatively use the binomial theorem:
$$11^{11}=(10+1)^{11}=sum_{k=0}^{11}binom{11}{k}10^k=binom{11}{0}10^0+binom{11}{1}10^1+binom{11}{2}10^2+ldots+binom{11}{11}10^{11}$$
$$=1+11*10+55*100+ldots+10^{11}=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)$$
$$12^{12}=(10+2)^{12}=sum_{k=0}^{12}binom{12}{k}10^k2^{12-k}=binom{12}{0}10^02^{12}+binom{12}{1}10^12^{11}+binom{12}{2}10^22^{10}+ldots+binom{12}{12}10^{12}=2^{12}+12*10*2^{11}+66*100*2^{10}+ldots+10^{12}$$ $$=2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)$$
$$13^{13}=(10+3)^{13}=sum_{k=0}^{13}binom{13}{k}10^k3^{13-k}=binom{13}{0}10^03^{13}+binom{13}{1}10^13^{12}+binom{13}{2}10^23^{11}+ldots+binom{13}{13}10^{13}=3^{13}+13*10*3^{12}+78*100*3^{11}+ldots+10^{13}$$ $$=3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$
Thus $${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}$$ $$=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)+2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)+3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$ $$=1+2^{12}+3^{13}+10Biggl(cdotsBiggr)$$
Now $$1+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+2^{3*4}+3^{3*4}*3=1+8^4+9^4*3=1+64^2+81^2*3$$ $$=1+4096+6561*3=23780Rightarrow 10mid (1+2^{12}+3^{13})$$
And we would be done.
PS:
I still find the modular approach easier and more elegant...
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
Note that $$11equiv1;mathtt{mod}(10) Rightarrow {11^{11}}equiv {1^{11}}equiv1 ;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Analugously $${12^{12}}equiv{2^{12}}equiv{(2^6)^2}equiv{64^2}equiv6;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$${13^{13}}equiv{(13^4)^2}*13equiv{1^2}*3equiv3; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Thus
$${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}equiv1+6+3equiv 0; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$$therefore10mid bigl({11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}bigr)$$
You can alternatively use the binomial theorem:
$$11^{11}=(10+1)^{11}=sum_{k=0}^{11}binom{11}{k}10^k=binom{11}{0}10^0+binom{11}{1}10^1+binom{11}{2}10^2+ldots+binom{11}{11}10^{11}$$
$$=1+11*10+55*100+ldots+10^{11}=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)$$
$$12^{12}=(10+2)^{12}=sum_{k=0}^{12}binom{12}{k}10^k2^{12-k}=binom{12}{0}10^02^{12}+binom{12}{1}10^12^{11}+binom{12}{2}10^22^{10}+ldots+binom{12}{12}10^{12}=2^{12}+12*10*2^{11}+66*100*2^{10}+ldots+10^{12}$$ $$=2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)$$
$$13^{13}=(10+3)^{13}=sum_{k=0}^{13}binom{13}{k}10^k3^{13-k}=binom{13}{0}10^03^{13}+binom{13}{1}10^13^{12}+binom{13}{2}10^23^{11}+ldots+binom{13}{13}10^{13}=3^{13}+13*10*3^{12}+78*100*3^{11}+ldots+10^{13}$$ $$=3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$
Thus $${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}$$ $$=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)+2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)+3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$ $$=1+2^{12}+3^{13}+10Biggl(cdotsBiggr)$$
Now $$1+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+2^{3*4}+3^{3*4}*3=1+8^4+9^4*3=1+64^2+81^2*3$$ $$=1+4096+6561*3=23780Rightarrow 10mid (1+2^{12}+3^{13})$$
And we would be done.
PS:
I still find the modular approach easier and more elegant...
add a comment |
up vote
0
down vote
up vote
0
down vote
Note that $$11equiv1;mathtt{mod}(10) Rightarrow {11^{11}}equiv {1^{11}}equiv1 ;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Analugously $${12^{12}}equiv{2^{12}}equiv{(2^6)^2}equiv{64^2}equiv6;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$${13^{13}}equiv{(13^4)^2}*13equiv{1^2}*3equiv3; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Thus
$${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}equiv1+6+3equiv 0; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$$therefore10mid bigl({11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}bigr)$$
You can alternatively use the binomial theorem:
$$11^{11}=(10+1)^{11}=sum_{k=0}^{11}binom{11}{k}10^k=binom{11}{0}10^0+binom{11}{1}10^1+binom{11}{2}10^2+ldots+binom{11}{11}10^{11}$$
$$=1+11*10+55*100+ldots+10^{11}=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)$$
$$12^{12}=(10+2)^{12}=sum_{k=0}^{12}binom{12}{k}10^k2^{12-k}=binom{12}{0}10^02^{12}+binom{12}{1}10^12^{11}+binom{12}{2}10^22^{10}+ldots+binom{12}{12}10^{12}=2^{12}+12*10*2^{11}+66*100*2^{10}+ldots+10^{12}$$ $$=2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)$$
$$13^{13}=(10+3)^{13}=sum_{k=0}^{13}binom{13}{k}10^k3^{13-k}=binom{13}{0}10^03^{13}+binom{13}{1}10^13^{12}+binom{13}{2}10^23^{11}+ldots+binom{13}{13}10^{13}=3^{13}+13*10*3^{12}+78*100*3^{11}+ldots+10^{13}$$ $$=3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$
Thus $${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}$$ $$=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)+2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)+3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$ $$=1+2^{12}+3^{13}+10Biggl(cdotsBiggr)$$
Now $$1+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+2^{3*4}+3^{3*4}*3=1+8^4+9^4*3=1+64^2+81^2*3$$ $$=1+4096+6561*3=23780Rightarrow 10mid (1+2^{12}+3^{13})$$
And we would be done.
PS:
I still find the modular approach easier and more elegant...
Note that $$11equiv1;mathtt{mod}(10) Rightarrow {11^{11}}equiv {1^{11}}equiv1 ;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Analugously $${12^{12}}equiv{2^{12}}equiv{(2^6)^2}equiv{64^2}equiv6;mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$${13^{13}}equiv{(13^4)^2}*13equiv{1^2}*3equiv3; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
Thus
$${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}equiv1+6+3equiv 0; mathtt{mod}(10)$$
$$therefore10mid bigl({11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}bigr)$$
You can alternatively use the binomial theorem:
$$11^{11}=(10+1)^{11}=sum_{k=0}^{11}binom{11}{k}10^k=binom{11}{0}10^0+binom{11}{1}10^1+binom{11}{2}10^2+ldots+binom{11}{11}10^{11}$$
$$=1+11*10+55*100+ldots+10^{11}=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)$$
$$12^{12}=(10+2)^{12}=sum_{k=0}^{12}binom{12}{k}10^k2^{12-k}=binom{12}{0}10^02^{12}+binom{12}{1}10^12^{11}+binom{12}{2}10^22^{10}+ldots+binom{12}{12}10^{12}=2^{12}+12*10*2^{11}+66*100*2^{10}+ldots+10^{12}$$ $$=2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)$$
$$13^{13}=(10+3)^{13}=sum_{k=0}^{13}binom{13}{k}10^k3^{13-k}=binom{13}{0}10^03^{13}+binom{13}{1}10^13^{12}+binom{13}{2}10^23^{11}+ldots+binom{13}{13}10^{13}=3^{13}+13*10*3^{12}+78*100*3^{11}+ldots+10^{13}$$ $$=3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$
Thus $${11^{11}}+{12^{12}}+{13^{13}}$$ $$=1+10Bigl(11+550+ldots+10^{10}Bigr)+2^{12}+10Bigl(12*2^{11}+660*2^{10}+ldots+10^{11}Bigr)+3^{13}+10Bigl(13*3^{12}+780*3^{11}+ldots+10^{12}Bigr)$$ $$=1+2^{12}+3^{13}+10Biggl(cdotsBiggr)$$
Now $$1+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+2^{3*4}+3^{3*4}*3=1+8^4+9^4*3=1+64^2+81^2*3$$ $$=1+4096+6561*3=23780Rightarrow 10mid (1+2^{12}+3^{13})$$
And we would be done.
PS:
I still find the modular approach easier and more elegant...
edited Nov 26 at 20:51
answered Nov 25 at 18:58
Dr. Mathva
742114
742114
add a comment |
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic.
$11equiv 1mod 10implies 11^{11}equiv 1mod 10$.
$12equiv 2mod 10implies 12^6equiv 2^6 mod10equiv 4mod 10$ $implies 12^{12}equiv 4^2mod 10equiv 6mod 10$.
$13equiv 3 mod 10implies 13^4equiv 3^4 mod 10equiv 1 mod 10implies 13^{13}equiv 3mod 10.$
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv 1+6+3 mod 10equiv 0 mod 10.$
Hence $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by 10.
"Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic." I think that's a big assumption. But $mod 10$ can be explained in one sentence to an extent that the OP can understand it
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:00
But it can get mathematical then. It would be based on logical arguments rather than mathematical deductions.
– Yadati Kiran
Nov 25 at 19:02
I absolutely agree!!!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:17
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic.
$11equiv 1mod 10implies 11^{11}equiv 1mod 10$.
$12equiv 2mod 10implies 12^6equiv 2^6 mod10equiv 4mod 10$ $implies 12^{12}equiv 4^2mod 10equiv 6mod 10$.
$13equiv 3 mod 10implies 13^4equiv 3^4 mod 10equiv 1 mod 10implies 13^{13}equiv 3mod 10.$
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv 1+6+3 mod 10equiv 0 mod 10.$
Hence $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by 10.
"Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic." I think that's a big assumption. But $mod 10$ can be explained in one sentence to an extent that the OP can understand it
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:00
But it can get mathematical then. It would be based on logical arguments rather than mathematical deductions.
– Yadati Kiran
Nov 25 at 19:02
I absolutely agree!!!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:17
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
up vote
-1
down vote
Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic.
$11equiv 1mod 10implies 11^{11}equiv 1mod 10$.
$12equiv 2mod 10implies 12^6equiv 2^6 mod10equiv 4mod 10$ $implies 12^{12}equiv 4^2mod 10equiv 6mod 10$.
$13equiv 3 mod 10implies 13^4equiv 3^4 mod 10equiv 1 mod 10implies 13^{13}equiv 3mod 10.$
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv 1+6+3 mod 10equiv 0 mod 10.$
Hence $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by 10.
Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic.
$11equiv 1mod 10implies 11^{11}equiv 1mod 10$.
$12equiv 2mod 10implies 12^6equiv 2^6 mod10equiv 4mod 10$ $implies 12^{12}equiv 4^2mod 10equiv 6mod 10$.
$13equiv 3 mod 10implies 13^4equiv 3^4 mod 10equiv 1 mod 10implies 13^{13}equiv 3mod 10.$
So $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}equiv 1+6+3 mod 10equiv 0 mod 10.$
Hence $11^{11}+12^{12}+13^{13}$ is divisible by 10.
answered Nov 25 at 18:55
Yadati Kiran
1,242417
1,242417
"Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic." I think that's a big assumption. But $mod 10$ can be explained in one sentence to an extent that the OP can understand it
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:00
But it can get mathematical then. It would be based on logical arguments rather than mathematical deductions.
– Yadati Kiran
Nov 25 at 19:02
I absolutely agree!!!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:17
add a comment |
"Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic." I think that's a big assumption. But $mod 10$ can be explained in one sentence to an extent that the OP can understand it
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:00
But it can get mathematical then. It would be based on logical arguments rather than mathematical deductions.
– Yadati Kiran
Nov 25 at 19:02
I absolutely agree!!!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:17
"Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic." I think that's a big assumption. But $mod 10$ can be explained in one sentence to an extent that the OP can understand it
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:00
"Assuming you have knowledge of modular arithmetic." I think that's a big assumption. But $mod 10$ can be explained in one sentence to an extent that the OP can understand it
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:00
But it can get mathematical then. It would be based on logical arguments rather than mathematical deductions.
– Yadati Kiran
Nov 25 at 19:02
But it can get mathematical then. It would be based on logical arguments rather than mathematical deductions.
– Yadati Kiran
Nov 25 at 19:02
I absolutely agree!!!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:17
I absolutely agree!!!
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:17
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
When calculating in (mod 10) we get $11^{11}+12^{12}+12^{13}=1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+6+3=10$. Here I knew $2^{10} =1024$, so $2^{12}=6(mod10)$ and $3$ has order $4$ in $mathbb{Z}/10mathbb{Z}$ so $3^{13}=3^{12}*3=3$.
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
When calculating in (mod 10) we get $11^{11}+12^{12}+12^{13}=1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+6+3=10$. Here I knew $2^{10} =1024$, so $2^{12}=6(mod10)$ and $3$ has order $4$ in $mathbb{Z}/10mathbb{Z}$ so $3^{13}=3^{12}*3=3$.
add a comment |
up vote
-1
down vote
up vote
-1
down vote
When calculating in (mod 10) we get $11^{11}+12^{12}+12^{13}=1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+6+3=10$. Here I knew $2^{10} =1024$, so $2^{12}=6(mod10)$ and $3$ has order $4$ in $mathbb{Z}/10mathbb{Z}$ so $3^{13}=3^{12}*3=3$.
When calculating in (mod 10) we get $11^{11}+12^{12}+12^{13}=1^{11}+2^{12}+3^{13}=1+6+3=10$. Here I knew $2^{10} =1024$, so $2^{12}=6(mod10)$ and $3$ has order $4$ in $mathbb{Z}/10mathbb{Z}$ so $3^{13}=3^{12}*3=3$.
answered Nov 25 at 18:55
mathnoob
1,433117
1,433117
add a comment |
add a comment |
Thanks for contributing an answer to Mathematics Stack Exchange!
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
Use MathJax to format equations. MathJax reference.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Some of your past answers have not been well-received, and you're in danger of being blocked from answering.
Please pay close attention to the following guidance:
- Please be sure to answer the question. Provide details and share your research!
But avoid …
- Asking for help, clarification, or responding to other answers.
- Making statements based on opinion; back them up with references or personal experience.
To learn more, see our tips on writing great answers.
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
StackExchange.ready(
function () {
StackExchange.openid.initPostLogin('.new-post-login', 'https%3a%2f%2fmath.stackexchange.com%2fquestions%2f3013212%2fshow-111112121313-10k-without-direct-calculation%23new-answer', 'question_page');
}
);
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Sign up or log in
StackExchange.ready(function () {
StackExchange.helpers.onClickDraftSave('#login-link');
});
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Sign up using Google
Sign up using Facebook
Sign up using Email and Password
Post as a guest
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
Required, but never shown
2
Do calculators now have enough precision to compute $13^{13}$ exactly?
– MJD
Nov 25 at 18:50
1
What about taking mod $10$ ??
– Anik Bhowmick
Nov 25 at 18:52
1
Working modulo $10$ is simply the same as only looking at the final digit. There are all sorts of ways of approaching this. The most efficient ones will use the tricks of modular arithmetic, which were designed for just such problems and encode the patterns which you will notice if you do more of the calculations by hand. I am sure you will get some elementary answers, but it is worth noting some of the other things people say as well, and either look them up, or look out for them as you learn, because you will find they come in handy to know.
– Mark Bennet
Nov 25 at 19:18
If $n$ has a last digit of $a$ and $m$ has a last digit of $b$ then $n =10k +a$ and $m=10j + b$. Note: $n^z=(10k + a)^z$ and all we are interested in is the last digit then it has the same last digit as $a^z$. And $n + m = 10k + 10j + a + b$ so we only have to consider those last digits. So this become a math based on "last digits" and that's much easier.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 19:28
FYI: Modulus arithmetic simply means doing arithmetic on remainders. The important thing is that to find the remainder of an expression with large values, it is good enough to do the expression on just the remainders. So the remaider of $32^9*43+52$ when divided by $7$ it's enough to take the remainder of $32:(4)$, the remainder of $43:(1)$ and the remainder of $52:(3)$ an find out the remainder of $4^9*1+3$. And to figure and $4^9$ we figure $4^2=16$ has remainder $2$. So $4^3$ has remainder $2*4=8$ which has remainder $1$. And $4^3$ has remainder $1*4=4$ and so on.
– fleablood
Nov 25 at 21:50