Find the set of interstion of $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ shwoing its elements...

Multi tool use
Multi tool use











up vote
1
down vote

favorite
2













This question already has an answer here:




  • Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? [closed]

    1 answer




This question is from $text{p-adic numbers}.$



My questions are-



$(1)$ Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? If non-empty, then what are the elements or the intersection set?



$(2)$ Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}_p $ non-empty? If non-empty what are the elements or the intersection set?



I can not conclude the answer.



Please someone help me with details answer or at least hints.










share|cite|improve this question













marked as duplicate by Torsten Schoeneberg, Ali Caglayan, Rebellos, José Carlos Santos, supinf Nov 29 at 14:41


This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.



















    up vote
    1
    down vote

    favorite
    2













    This question already has an answer here:




    • Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? [closed]

      1 answer




    This question is from $text{p-adic numbers}.$



    My questions are-



    $(1)$ Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? If non-empty, then what are the elements or the intersection set?



    $(2)$ Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}_p $ non-empty? If non-empty what are the elements or the intersection set?



    I can not conclude the answer.



    Please someone help me with details answer or at least hints.










    share|cite|improve this question













    marked as duplicate by Torsten Schoeneberg, Ali Caglayan, Rebellos, José Carlos Santos, supinf Nov 29 at 14:41


    This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.

















      up vote
      1
      down vote

      favorite
      2









      up vote
      1
      down vote

      favorite
      2






      2






      This question already has an answer here:




      • Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? [closed]

        1 answer




      This question is from $text{p-adic numbers}.$



      My questions are-



      $(1)$ Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? If non-empty, then what are the elements or the intersection set?



      $(2)$ Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}_p $ non-empty? If non-empty what are the elements or the intersection set?



      I can not conclude the answer.



      Please someone help me with details answer or at least hints.










      share|cite|improve this question














      This question already has an answer here:




      • Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? [closed]

        1 answer




      This question is from $text{p-adic numbers}.$



      My questions are-



      $(1)$ Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? If non-empty, then what are the elements or the intersection set?



      $(2)$ Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}_p $ non-empty? If non-empty what are the elements or the intersection set?



      I can not conclude the answer.



      Please someone help me with details answer or at least hints.





      This question already has an answer here:




      • Is the set $ (mathbb{Z}_p setminus mathbb{Z}) cap mathbb{Q}$ non-empty? [closed]

        1 answer








      p-adic-number-theory






      share|cite|improve this question













      share|cite|improve this question











      share|cite|improve this question




      share|cite|improve this question










      asked Nov 29 at 4:08









      M. A. SARKAR

      2,1271619




      2,1271619




      marked as duplicate by Torsten Schoeneberg, Ali Caglayan, Rebellos, José Carlos Santos, supinf Nov 29 at 14:41


      This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.






      marked as duplicate by Torsten Schoeneberg, Ali Caglayan, Rebellos, José Carlos Santos, supinf Nov 29 at 14:41


      This question has been asked before and already has an answer. If those answers do not fully address your question, please ask a new question.
























          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes

















          up vote
          1
          down vote













          Hint: $frac{1}{2} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$, since $$frac{1}{2}= frac{-1}{1-3} = -1-3-9-27- dots.$$ That (1) is nonempty implies that (2) is.



          Similarly, you can prove that any $frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$ so long $3 nmid b.$






          share|cite|improve this answer























          • yes that is one element and so non-empty.. But I need to find the whole and general expression of the intersection set .. Can you do that that for general $p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:17












          • Simply inductive construct the inverse power series of $b$ for $frac{1}{b}.$
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:19










          • Does $ frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Q}_p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:19






          • 1




            Yes. $mathbb{Q}_p supset mathbb{Q}$.
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:20






          • 1




            Asking someone to put an answer in that special form sounds like you are asking someone to provide the answer to a homework question. That is not a reasonable request.
            – KCd
            Nov 29 at 6:28


















          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes








          1 Answer
          1






          active

          oldest

          votes









          active

          oldest

          votes






          active

          oldest

          votes








          up vote
          1
          down vote













          Hint: $frac{1}{2} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$, since $$frac{1}{2}= frac{-1}{1-3} = -1-3-9-27- dots.$$ That (1) is nonempty implies that (2) is.



          Similarly, you can prove that any $frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$ so long $3 nmid b.$






          share|cite|improve this answer























          • yes that is one element and so non-empty.. But I need to find the whole and general expression of the intersection set .. Can you do that that for general $p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:17












          • Simply inductive construct the inverse power series of $b$ for $frac{1}{b}.$
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:19










          • Does $ frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Q}_p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:19






          • 1




            Yes. $mathbb{Q}_p supset mathbb{Q}$.
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:20






          • 1




            Asking someone to put an answer in that special form sounds like you are asking someone to provide the answer to a homework question. That is not a reasonable request.
            – KCd
            Nov 29 at 6:28















          up vote
          1
          down vote













          Hint: $frac{1}{2} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$, since $$frac{1}{2}= frac{-1}{1-3} = -1-3-9-27- dots.$$ That (1) is nonempty implies that (2) is.



          Similarly, you can prove that any $frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$ so long $3 nmid b.$






          share|cite|improve this answer























          • yes that is one element and so non-empty.. But I need to find the whole and general expression of the intersection set .. Can you do that that for general $p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:17












          • Simply inductive construct the inverse power series of $b$ for $frac{1}{b}.$
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:19










          • Does $ frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Q}_p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:19






          • 1




            Yes. $mathbb{Q}_p supset mathbb{Q}$.
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:20






          • 1




            Asking someone to put an answer in that special form sounds like you are asking someone to provide the answer to a homework question. That is not a reasonable request.
            – KCd
            Nov 29 at 6:28













          up vote
          1
          down vote










          up vote
          1
          down vote









          Hint: $frac{1}{2} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$, since $$frac{1}{2}= frac{-1}{1-3} = -1-3-9-27- dots.$$ That (1) is nonempty implies that (2) is.



          Similarly, you can prove that any $frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$ so long $3 nmid b.$






          share|cite|improve this answer














          Hint: $frac{1}{2} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$, since $$frac{1}{2}= frac{-1}{1-3} = -1-3-9-27- dots.$$ That (1) is nonempty implies that (2) is.



          Similarly, you can prove that any $frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Z}_3 setminus mathbb{Z}$ so long $3 nmid b.$







          share|cite|improve this answer














          share|cite|improve this answer



          share|cite|improve this answer








          edited Nov 29 at 4:17

























          answered Nov 29 at 4:15









          Dzoooks

          846316




          846316












          • yes that is one element and so non-empty.. But I need to find the whole and general expression of the intersection set .. Can you do that that for general $p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:17












          • Simply inductive construct the inverse power series of $b$ for $frac{1}{b}.$
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:19










          • Does $ frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Q}_p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:19






          • 1




            Yes. $mathbb{Q}_p supset mathbb{Q}$.
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:20






          • 1




            Asking someone to put an answer in that special form sounds like you are asking someone to provide the answer to a homework question. That is not a reasonable request.
            – KCd
            Nov 29 at 6:28


















          • yes that is one element and so non-empty.. But I need to find the whole and general expression of the intersection set .. Can you do that that for general $p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:17












          • Simply inductive construct the inverse power series of $b$ for $frac{1}{b}.$
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:19










          • Does $ frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Q}_p$?
            – M. A. SARKAR
            Nov 29 at 4:19






          • 1




            Yes. $mathbb{Q}_p supset mathbb{Q}$.
            – Dzoooks
            Nov 29 at 4:20






          • 1




            Asking someone to put an answer in that special form sounds like you are asking someone to provide the answer to a homework question. That is not a reasonable request.
            – KCd
            Nov 29 at 6:28
















          yes that is one element and so non-empty.. But I need to find the whole and general expression of the intersection set .. Can you do that that for general $p$?
          – M. A. SARKAR
          Nov 29 at 4:17






          yes that is one element and so non-empty.. But I need to find the whole and general expression of the intersection set .. Can you do that that for general $p$?
          – M. A. SARKAR
          Nov 29 at 4:17














          Simply inductive construct the inverse power series of $b$ for $frac{1}{b}.$
          – Dzoooks
          Nov 29 at 4:19




          Simply inductive construct the inverse power series of $b$ for $frac{1}{b}.$
          – Dzoooks
          Nov 29 at 4:19












          Does $ frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Q}_p$?
          – M. A. SARKAR
          Nov 29 at 4:19




          Does $ frac{a}{b} in mathbb{Q}_p$?
          – M. A. SARKAR
          Nov 29 at 4:19




          1




          1




          Yes. $mathbb{Q}_p supset mathbb{Q}$.
          – Dzoooks
          Nov 29 at 4:20




          Yes. $mathbb{Q}_p supset mathbb{Q}$.
          – Dzoooks
          Nov 29 at 4:20




          1




          1




          Asking someone to put an answer in that special form sounds like you are asking someone to provide the answer to a homework question. That is not a reasonable request.
          – KCd
          Nov 29 at 6:28




          Asking someone to put an answer in that special form sounds like you are asking someone to provide the answer to a homework question. That is not a reasonable request.
          – KCd
          Nov 29 at 6:28



          E,Sjw2D0p,HVjNmKdZ85IcfvozP69yDv2 J,6Lbg2wZ
          t2 2pwl5td,ZLc,dg10z8mRku3,pBgbYxiZhqj

          Popular posts from this blog

          UPSERT syntax error linked to UPDATE in PostgreSQL (python)

          Some classess of my CSS file are not rendering into Django templates (most classess render without problems)

          Sphinx de Gizeh